Avatar image for liquiddragon
Posted by liquiddragon (3290 posts) 7 months, 28 days ago

Poll: How is Mario + Rabbids? (119 votes)

⭐️ 0%
⭐️⭐️ 3%
⭐️⭐️⭐️ 18%
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 39%
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 7%
Show me the poll. 33%

Hey, I got a Switch very recently and this is a game I’m very curious about. I love Valkyria Chronicles and mostly love XCOM:EU but I’m not completely sold on M+R yet.

The sense I got was that it made quite the impression initially but players didn’t find the depth a good one of these have further they got into the game. I could be wrong on that but enthusiasms for the game did seem to peter out and I wondered why.

What do you think about this game? What’s good, what’s bad? Please no spoilers if there are any.

Thanks.

Avatar image for gkhan
#1 Posted by gkhan (1052 posts) -

It's fine. It's a bit too liberal with movement for my taste (the characters can run and tackle and jump really far compared to XCOM), but it's a perfectly decent tactics game. I also enjoyed the puzzles outside of the combat. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#2 Posted by liquiddragon (3290 posts) -

@gkhan: lol it’s fine, 4/5 stars?

Avatar image for gkhan
#3 Edited by gkhan (1052 posts) -

@liquiddragon said:

@gkhan: lol it’s fine, 4/5 stars?

Yeah. It's fine. It's a good game without any major problems, but it's not going to rock your world. 4/5 stars :)

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#4 Posted by liquiddragon (3290 posts) -

This is why I’m not quite sold on this game. Ppl score using their brain but speak from the heart.

I see this happen every year. Some games will review well but if you listen to the conversation, it doesn’t add up why. I think ppl still have a hard time scoring a functioning polished game a low score even if it doesn’t have “it.”

Not sure if M+R falls in this category but I notice it a lot with major releases.

Avatar image for nutter
#5 Posted by nutter (1966 posts) -

It’s fine. I think it’s fun enough, but it gets more demanding than fun. It feels like there are calculated runs that could get you through the game, as RNG is a minimal part of combat. Combat plays out more like a puzzle (to make up for this?).

I also don’t like the overworld and find the Rabbid characters generally obnoxious, aside from Rabbid Mario, who seems like an alright dude.

Avatar image for kingbonesaw
#6 Posted by KingBonesaw (1380 posts) -

I’ve only played the first 2 worlds and have really enjoyed it but Jeff’s review a while back does point out that the game wears out its welcome eventually. I’m mostly unfamiliar with this type of game (I only played some XCOM on Vita which is not a good way to play that game) so I haven’t had issues with the game being too forgiving but veterans of the genre might find it to be an issue.

It is also the only Mario game that consistently goes on sale below MSRP and I do think it is worth checking out at a lowered price. I don’t want to leave a review score since I haven’t finished it.

I also understand your bit about review scores, Axiom Verge and Horizon are two of my favourite games in recent years, both scored higher than most games on the website but got next to zero representation during GOTY.

Avatar image for nutter
#7 Posted by nutter (1966 posts) -

@liquiddragon: I feel like hype has gotten out of hand, lately:

- Mario vs. Rabbids

- Mario Tennis

- Horizon going from hysteric hype to forgotten a month later when Zelda came out and by several accounts, made Horizon feel immediately antiquated.

I’ve held off on God of War so far as 1) I don’t have a ton of time and 2) I just can’t trust the universal day one praise any more. It looks great, but I don’t need to play games day one and I don’t need the extreme hype influencing me.

It feels like people get super excited for the flavor of the week. I guess we always have, but for some reason it feels less earned...maybe I’m just older and less invested in games...

Avatar image for savage
#8 Posted by Savage (781 posts) -

The Giant Bomb review covers the story mode pretty well (3/5 stars). But I really enjoyed the ultimate challenge levels after the story. Your team has nearly maxed out capabilities at that point and those levels hold nothing back, so you get to fully explore what's possible with the game's clever gameplay systems. You have to very carefully think through your team composition and each move you make in battle. At first glance, some of those challenge levels look completely crazy and impossible. But then you start trying out some team compositions, working out combo chains, and the possibility of success gradually comes into focus. Finishing those levels really made me appreciate how well designed the combat gameplay was. That was easily my favorite part of the game (5/5 stars).

Avatar image for meteora3255
#9 Posted by meteora3255 (678 posts) -

My biggest problem is that it is too long and doesn't have enough going on to justify the length. I really enjoy the combat and tone but after awhile the encounters all kind of bleed together. With the exception of the boss encounters, none of them feel unique after awhile. That said I still enjoyed my time with it and definitely think it's one of the better games on Switch that isn't a remake/rerelease.

Avatar image for flashflood_29
#10 Posted by FlashFlood_29 (4401 posts) -

5 stars for me. The perfect balance of tactics without much BS chance getting in the way. Like it's often stated, it can feel like a puzzle at times in terms of how to best the field of enemies, but it never stops feeling like a tactics game where there is a need to adapt and think on the fly.

The humor hit with me real well and out of battle puzzles were enjoyable for the most part, to break up the pace of battle after battle. End game offers great challenge and variation to test player's ability. On top of that, there is now DLC.

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#11 Posted by liquiddragon (3290 posts) -

Not many ppl actually played this huh?

Avatar image for john1912
#12 Posted by John1912 (2504 posts) -

I bought it. Was fun! Give it 4/5. Not amazing but good waste of time, and dont regret the purchase. Could have been a little deeper in combat.

Avatar image for frodobaggins
#13 Edited by FrodoBaggins (2024 posts) -

@liquiddragon: I've just bought the game two days ago. I'm about 3 hours in. It's ok, maybe a little slow for my taste thus far, and I can't play it for long stretches. I do a couple battles and I have to put it down.

Thus far, 3 stars.

Avatar image for flashflood_29
#14 Posted by FlashFlood_29 (4401 posts) -

@liquiddragon: You got 53 votes and a handful of replies on a game that's over a year old and was a hot topic of reception at it's time. People have exhausted what they have to say about the game long before you made this thread.

Avatar image for liquiddragon
#15 Posted by liquiddragon (3290 posts) -

@flashflood_29: Na dude, I ask about old(er) games all the time. This game has less than 10 dedicated forum threads and just one of them with a decent amount of replies. I don’t think that many ppl played this, atleast st GB.

Avatar image for frodobaggins
#16 Posted by FrodoBaggins (2024 posts) -

@flashflood_29: I think making a thread like this, a year after release, has merit. Not everybody plays games as they are released. Lots of people pick them up at a later date and wish to talk about them.

Avatar image for htr10
#17 Posted by htr10 (1031 posts) -

I play a lot more games that are over a year old than I do games that came out the current year. No harm in asking for people’s opinions on video games on this video game website.

Avatar image for haneybd87
#18 Edited by haneybd87 (387 posts) -

The tactical combat is super fun and surprisingly deep, the art style is really amazing in a fun and happy way. The only problem is all the puzzle stuff between the combat sections. I wouldn’t mind that stuff so much if you didn’t just get art and music unlockables 75% of the time. It’s annoying to go through a difficult puzzle and have it just be a song instead of upgrade points. That all said, the puzzle stuff is really my only gripe here and the combat and art style are enough to give this 4/5. This game just puts me into a happy place.

Avatar image for flashflood_29
#19 Posted by FlashFlood_29 (4401 posts) -

@liquiddragon: Eh, I talked about it a lot with a bunch of duders on discord.

Avatar image for rawkpartee
#20 Posted by rawkpartee (16 posts) -

I’d say rent it or wait for it to be 20 bucks, it’s fun, but didn’t hold my interest for more than a few levels.

Avatar image for blackichigo
#22 Posted by blackichigo (433 posts) -

I think it's a decent game that goes on way too long. At times it felt less like a tactical RPG and more like a puzzle game, which I found to be pretty cool. But once I got to the third world I had very little desire to actually pick that game up and play it again. It's not that it was bad or anything. It was just hella repetitive.

Honestly every time I played it I ended up thinking, "Man, I should play Xcom again."

Avatar image for alias
#23 Posted by Alias (47 posts) -

I thought it was great. It can feel like it drags a little but I broke up my time with it largely into bursts of a few levels every other day. There are some very memorable moments in that game (the opera boss battle in particular) and I would recommend it to anyone with a Switch and interest in the genre.