Avatar image for thanatos3
#1 Posted by Thanatos3 (92 posts) -

So i have the Mass Effect Trilogy for the ps3 and thus have played ME2 first in 2011 and ME3 in 2012 and just recently played ME1 for the first time and noticed how broken the lore of these games are. Joker says that his legs are the only problem he has and yet minutes into ME2 he complains that you grab his arm and you hear his bones creaking, later the ribs, and so on in ME2/3. The more I played ME1 and later 2 again after the story just falls apart with the lore. Why did people still care by the end of ME3 anyway?

Avatar image for flstyle
#2 Posted by FLStyle (6256 posts) -

So i have the Mass Effect Trilogy for the ps3 and thus have played ME2 first in 2011 and ME3 in 2012 and just recently played ME1 for the first time and noticed how broken the lore of these games are. Joker says that his legs are the only problem he has and yet minutes into ME2 he complains that you grab his arm and you hear his bones creaking, later the ribs, and so on in ME2/3. The more I played ME1 and later 2 again after the story just falls apart with the lore. Why did people still care by the end of ME3 anyway?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osteogenesis_imperfecta

Your assumption that brittle bone disease (which Joker mentions by name) only affects one part of the body is a poor one.

Avatar image for thanatos3
#3 Posted by Thanatos3 (92 posts) -

@flstyle: He also specifically says it only affects his legs, extends from the hips down i believe he says. Oh and then he totally shoots an assault rifle at the end of the game...

Avatar image for chrissedoff
#4 Posted by chrissedoff (2353 posts) -

@thanatos3: I think what he says is he's broken bones in his legs many times and has trouble walking as a result.

Avatar image for mikejflick
#5 Posted by MikeJFlick (452 posts) -

Joker went from you touch me too hard I'll die

to

Shepard don't throw me so hard

to

I'm fine.

Avatar image for nictel
#6 Posted by Nictel (2695 posts) -

I thought Cerberus fixed him up at the beginning of ME2? But that his legs were too messed up to be truly fixed.

Avatar image for brodehouse
#7 Posted by Brodehouse (10827 posts) -

I think different writers had different interpretations.

I personally prefer the brittle legs thing, because I could see you becoming a star military pilot with a moderate handicap, but a full body thing is a bit much.

Avatar image for jaffaz
#8 Edited by jaffaz (193 posts) -

@mikejflick said:

Joker went from you touch me too hard I'll die

to

Shepard don't throw me so hard

to

I'm fine.

This is so perfectly succinct. Well said.

Avatar image for fredchuckdave
#9 Posted by Fredchuckdave (10237 posts) -

Too much titan

Online
Avatar image for onan
#10 Posted by onan (1352 posts) -

He's always had brittle bone disease, not sure where you got the "legs only" thing. Probably an assumption from him calling himself a cripple.

It's been handled oddly a lot, but no worse than in the last minute of ME3 (spoilers, obviously) when after the Normandy crash-lands on an uninhabited planet, dude is the first person walking out of the ship. Every bone in his body should have been turned to dust in a crash like that.

Avatar image for monkeyking1969
#11 Posted by MonkeyKing1969 (6232 posts) -

Joker is merely the victim of unimportant character syndrome in the first game. In the first game he is window dressing, they are not going to use him so he's can be portrayed with a memorable disease to add flavor. But, players liked his snark, so for game two the developers want to give him a roll, but to play a roll he has to be capable of doing SOMETHING, it is hard but he saves the ship. Therefor by game three he is a crucial character and he really does have to be useful, not breaking a hip like a Golden Girl, so they just put any infirmities to the background.