Do the ends justify the means? An age old question. A simple, yet important question.
Do the ends justify the means?
i wish you would elaborate more cause the means could be worse than what results in the ends. as for the genophage i think it was justified, were they suppose to let the krogan overrun the galaxy?
What end? And with what means? With that said, in most cases when people say "The ends justified the means" they are saying, "I/we were too lazy to wait for a fair solution so we took their rights away, we killed them, or we plowed over their village." Anyone who says "The ends justified the means" you should consider punching in the face just on principal because they likely had it coming -- if not from you then from someone.
'Bad' ends versus 'good' ends. Spare me. The real difficulty with this question is that the distinction between ends and means aren't as easily distinguished as it seems. Say the US bombs a village of 1,000 people to smithereens and kills a couple terrorists who would have killed 100,000 people if allowed to live. If all that happened was that 99,000 people were saved on the whole, then sure, sounds like something that would be in the US' best interests. But another end of this situation is that the US will be expected to use similar means in the future, so the US will have less trust, so the US might not learn about the next group of terrorists, and so the number of people saved steadily decreases and the end may turn out being that the US saved fewer lives by employing unpopular means in the first place. In general, when "the end justifies the means" is employed as an argument, a means is justified using a short term end and the long term end caused by the nature of the means is not considered. But when considered as an absolute abstract proposition, a->b (and only b), b is good, therefore a is good, I say yes. So I voted yes.
...but he was starving.Dude's starving, steals a loaf of bread to stay alive: FINE!Dude's starving, kills a child and eats her to stay alive: NOT FINE!
Please Log In to post.


Log in to comment