Is the spice girl's "2 become 1 a classic?"

Alright so I understand that typically classics are older songs that have either some significant meaning in their contextual time frame, or they will do so in the future, or in some cases just have the feeling of a time that has passed and brings to mind older times. At any rate I listen to a pinch of Spice Girls every now and then and I was just wondering what you guys thought.

To bring a bit of context I was born in 1992 so is it at all possible to say that this song with its soft melodic melody and harmonies be considered classic? 

I miss the Spice Girls. 
 
Secret between us, I used to have a really big crush on Baby Spice when I was a kid.  No idea why, but she was the one I wanted to mary.  I was in fourth grade back then too.  

No. Really, no. And I used to love them.
 
In my defence, I was 12.

No, but Geri Halliwell looked fine in it.  That's the redhead in case you're wondering.

Dear God I miss the spice girls.... 
 
I also miss these guys :( 
  

Fuck yes it is! Every Spice Girls song was an instant classic! What kind of a monster would think otherwise?

The Spice Girls are great. 
On mute.

" @Sin4profit:  I'm pretty damn sure none of them were "pudgy"... :-/ "

" No. Really, no. And I used to love them.  In my defence, I was 12. "

Only when Paul Gilbert does it
  

" @kittencake said:

" @Sin4profit:  I'm pretty damn sure none of them were "pudgy"... :-/ "

Jeri spice, the one that we found out did porn years later, was kind of pudgy. But in all the right places imho. "

Soo...On that video that crusader posted...
 
They look like prostitutes.

" @crusader8463 said:

" @kittencake said:

" @Sin4profit:  I'm pretty damn sure none of them were "pudgy"... :-/ "

Jeri spice, the one that we found out did porn years later, was kind of pudgy. But in all the right places imho. "

That's odd, I remember hearing that the group broke up because 2 of the spices were pregnant...but that was not the truth either, I think this was back when I didn't know about the meaning of rumors. Baby spice and sporty spice were my faves...anyone remember the amazing spice girls movie...yep. That and Nsync is what you get from having an older sister....oh the memories ha "

" Soo...On that video that crusader posted...  They look like prostitutes. "

John Lennon's "Imagine" is classic. 
 
Led Zeppelin's "Whole Lotta Love" is classic. 
 
Beethoven's 5th is classic. 
 
The Spice Girls' "2 Become 1"...is goddamn legendary.

It's a classic...I know this because even I know the bloody words to it lol
 
But yeah, the Spice Girls had some feel-good hits - thousands would agree and this was a good Chirstmas song.

2 Become 1 is probably the most modern song in my Christmas canon.

" I miss the Spice Girls.  Secret between us, I used to have a really big crush on Baby Spice when I was a kid.  No idea why, but she was the one I wanted to mary.  I was in fourth grade back then too.   "

Definitely not in my mind.

Spice Girls were probably one of the best girl groups, but definitely not as good as TLC, now TLC Waterfalls is a definite classic

Goddamn the 90s was awesome.

" Spice Girls were probably one of the best girl groups, but definitely not as good as TLC, now TLC Waterfalls is a definite classic "

" anyone who say's they did not enjoy at least one of their songs is a liar, it was made for you to like it, that's why you don't like it.    "

Damn I used to be a massive spice girls fan as a kid. 2 become 1 was most likely my favorite song as well. Dunno if i could listen through it now though.

Friend of mine used to always say "buncha hoes" everytime anyone said "spice girls."  And he never said it overtly either.  Just low  key.  Almost pavlonian.
 
None of us liked them much.  And we'd make fun of anyone who did.  You know, kids being kids.
 
Still don't listen to them, but eventually learned enough about them to understand what they had to overcome from the industry trying to force them into the standard mold.  And the fact that they stuck together and stuck to their guns and wrote their own songs and everything... Well, I may not have their cd in my car, but you still have to respect them.  Feel a little weird actually, having lumped them into the whole fabricated music scene.
 
As for "is it a classic?"  No.  That would make me old.  And I don't want to be old.

@xhavoc86 said:

" Spice Girls were probably one of the best girl groups, but definitely not as good as TLC, now TLC Waterfalls is a definite classic "

Yup, Spice Girls pretty much ripped off TLC's sound. Waterfalls is a classic, as is Ain't 2 Proud 2 Beg and maybe No Scrubs. I think Wannabe is the only SG song which even approaches classic status and in my opinion it's definitely not a classic.

2 spice girls, 1 cup. No it's not a classic, I think their first song is more than this one.

Nope

I still have Spice World on VHS. You heard me, I said VHS. Having said that, 2 Become 1 is not a classic. Say You'll Be There however, that is a classic in by any definition of the term.
 
  

Fuck. Yes.

Oh shit oh shit oh shit I gotta get outta this thread!!!

" @ape_dosmil

@xhavoc86 said:

" Spice Girls were probably one of the best girl groups, but definitely not as good as TLC, now TLC Waterfalls is a definite classic "

Yup, Spice Girls pretty much ripped off TLC's sound. Waterfalls is a classic, as is Ain't 2 Proud 2 Beg and maybe No Scrubs. I think Wannabe is the only SG song which even approaches classic status and in my opinion it's definitely not a classic.

Considering the time frame of releases and the fact that SG didn't write any of their songs they weren't really ripping anyone off they were in that wave of pop bands that really overshadowed everthing in their time TLC is a favorite of mine but my least favorite song of theirs is probably waterfalls...I honestly can't stand it I much prefer "Unpretty" that's a classic. "

" I still have Spice World on VHS. You heard me, I said VHS. Having said that, 2 Become 1 is not a classic. Say You'll Be There however, that is a classic in by any definition of the term.
 
  

What? did the spice girls do two girls 1 cup?