The Thing - 4/5
Better than I gave it credit for after I watched it about seven years ago. The paranoia... I'm also impressed by the versatility of Ennio Morricone. The music is so different from his other stuff. It's simplistic, but effective. I'm told some of it was also written by John Carpenter.
The Big Heat (1953) - 4/5
American noir by Fritz Lang (M, Metropolis). Very good. Surprisingly violent for an American movie of that time.
Sicario - 3/5.
Ghost in the Shell (2017) - 2/5
Average. Dumbed down for the action-hungry average moviegoers. People so bloodthirsty that they apparently need Aramaki to execute the bad guy, rather than arrest him. Though, I don't really care how faithful it is to the source material. I would have distanced it even more so that it's not in this awkward position of copying the old, sometimes scene for scene, while trying to tell a new story. My American Ghost in the Shell adaptation would have given the characters western names and set the story in future Los Angeles. It could work. The L.A. of Blade Runner is barely recognizable. Nobody cared that The Departed wasn't set in Hong Kong or that Kurosawa's Shakespeare adaptations were set in Japan. Make it your own. Show me new scenes.
Major has one of the worst haircuts I've seen in sci-fi. An uneven fringe, long on the sides and cut really short in the back. The hair also defies gravity, somehow.
http://i.imgur.com/kteVHGR.jpg
Anime hair doesn't translate to live action. Aramaki's hair looks silly too. Also, Scarlett (I don't know how to spell her last name.) is too short. I'd have liked to see someone more muscular in the role. Not sure who. At least Emily Blunt from Edge of Tomorrow and that Mexican woman from Aliens worked out of their action roles. I would think the perfect shell would be more fit and ideal, especially one designed for combat. The muscles may be artificial, but they function just like real muscles. It's also pretty obvious Scarlett doesn't know how to fight from how chopped up the action scenes are.
The world looks fake. The giant holograms (seemingly projected without interfering lights) were too much, the tech is too fantastic, and you can tell that almost everything in the city is computer generated. The streets of Hong Kong are strangely free of traffic. Major rides her bike down a freeway with the road completely to herself, and much earlier Bato drives his sports car down an empty market-type street.
Overall, I'm not that bothered. I kind of enjoyed this even, despite some of the stupidity. I've always appreciated Ghost in the Shell, but I find the whole franchise overrated, from the manga to the movies and TV show. The sci-fi manga go... Battle Angel Alita > Akira > Blame! > Ghost in the Shell. The Akira movie is also better than Ghost in the Shell ever was. It's an awe-inspiring audio-visual experience, featuring some of the best animation Japan has ever produced (I believe it's the only Japanese animation with full lip sync.) and an amazing score by the Geinoh Yamashirogumi group. I would also put the Nausicaa manga at the top, but I consider it more fantasy.
Log in to comment