Trek. As much as I love star wars, it isn't really sci-fi, it's more fantasy in space than science fiction, so it doesn't really belong with gate or trek.I never got into Stargate. I loved the original film, but just couldn't get into the series. So that leaves star trek, which I absolutely love.
Stargate. SG1, Atlantis and Universe are all great. It just needs to work on it's films as there rather suckish i think. Trek is past it's time and star wars...well that's a good idea gone wrong. So much crap in that universe you have to dig deep to find the good.
Wars. Didn't really like the first two prequels, but Revenge of the Sith really worked for me. And the new Clone Wars TV show has been surprisingly good, after the rather disasterous movie.
Always quite liked Trek too, but not to any level of fanatisism. And I was a fan of Gate, but SG-1 went on far longer than it needed to, Atlantis was very poorly planned out and quickly fell apart and I've never had any interest in seeing Universe.
One of the actors from the ORIGINAL trilogy is responsible for that scene ;) There was also a horrifying scene between Anakin and Padme, but other than that I did enjoy Episode III. Definitely had its flaws, but it was the only prequel movie that seemed to serve a purpose.
Ah, that horrible horrible scene. It was hilarious though. In a bad way.
I agree that Star Wars is a mix of fantasy and sci-fi, whereas the others are much more sci-fi, especially Trek. But Trek and Gate don't have a KotOR, or TOR, so Wars wins.
Egh, this poll is torture. Overall, I have to say the plot and acting is better to me in Stargate SG-1 (until after the point where the series was supposed to end but didn't) than Star Wars. As much as I loved Star Wars, I've got a real soft spot for ancient history. Shanks made that show.
Well, the first 3 Star Wars movies are more fun than most of what passes for "popcorn" entertainment these days. But, of course, TV is different than movies so stories can take longer to unfold. I really enjoyed Deep Space Nine and many an episode of SG1, so I voted all three. However, all franchises have had their problems, too. Star Wars has the prequels and that flaccid CG animated show on the Cartoon Network, Star Trek had Enterprise and the odd-numbered films, and Stargate had Atlantis as well as the better left forgotten cartoon, Stargate: Infinity. Nothing is perfect. If I was going to be completely honest, I'd say I prefer Farscape to either of the TV shows. Plus, right now in my life, I'd rather watch Wall-E again than anything mentioned above.
Star Wars is the only among those even slightly interesting. I've seen a few good episodes of Stargate but don't care for the series as a whole and the only good thing about Star Trek is Q.
I like Stargate, but I haven't watched much Star Trek. I don't really think Starwars is a fair thing to compare to TV shows. I picked it though because it's awesome, the original three anyway.
Log in to comment