Avatar image for sethmode
#1 Edited by SethMode (2019 posts) -

I had my eye on this not only because I'm a fan of Avatar, but also because Danika went to work there and had great stuff to say. It did not disappoint. However, it moves fast, just like the Castlevania series, and I wonder if this is the future of Netflix cartoons. Not that it's a bad thing, I'd rather shows be more like the Venture Bros. than most serialized shows but, I'm just left having watched 9 episodes where a LOT happens in very little time and now I have no idea how long the wait will be until the next batch.

I'm not entirely sure what the point of this thread is in retrospect other than to say that the show is great and I wish that there was more right now.

Avatar image for do_the_manta_ray
#2 Posted by Do_The_Manta_Ray (1638 posts) -

@sethmode: The point of the thread COULD be to serve as a recommendation to other duders, such as myself. I think I'll be checking it out after hearing you sing it's praises. Cheers, duder!

Avatar image for frodobaggins
#3 Posted by FrodoBaggins (2067 posts) -

I will also look at this, thanks.

Avatar image for acura_max
#4 Posted by Acura_Max (767 posts) -

Wow, you just reminded me that this show existed. It was one of the shows I was looking forward to and I forgotten that it released this month.

Avatar image for hankrazorbeard
#5 Edited by hankrazorbeard (121 posts) -

I'll definitely give it a look because of the association with Avatar: The Last Airbender, and maybe a little bit because of Danika. 3D animation has never been my thing outside of video games and from the trailers I saw I don't think this show will change my mind. It looked very cheap, especially because of the low framerate (that doesn't have the STYLLLEEE of something like Into the Spiderverse).

Avatar image for octaslash
#6 Posted by Octaslash (770 posts) -

The animation is definitely something you have to get used to. A similar 2D/3D blend was used in Tron Uprising. After a while my brain just saw it as 2D, with pretty well animated characters.

The writing is really solid and the humor is kid friendly, but not completely childish. It’s not really anything like Avatar.

Keep in mind, that “season one” is just 9 episodes and most likely just the front of a 22 episode season. Netflix did something similar with Voltron.

Avatar image for shadypingu
#7 Edited by ShadyPingu (1813 posts) -

I shotgunned the whole yesterday and really enjoyed it. Would like more of the general with the big fuck-off shield, please.

Avatar image for nietzschecookie
#8 Posted by NietzscheCookie (122 posts) -

I was looking forward to the writing quality, as the creator Aaron Ehasz wrote pretty much every great Avatar episode. But I was sceptical of the 2D-3D blend. It was pretty awesome overall in look and story. I feel like the animation framerate could be just a bit higher, but I would believe it if somebody told me that its already at the max value before it turns into 3D garbage.

Avatar image for epidehl
#9 Edited by Epidehl (716 posts) -

Just finished it myself and I still can't really get into the look at all. Character and story-wise it was entertaining enough, but anytime the animation wasn't fluid, like it was for action scenes, it looked distractingly weird/bad. Like, there were points where it looked like a video game struggling to keep a frame rate up, which is not a good look.

It's a shame more CGI stuff can't look as good as Land of the Lustrous, which is still the only show that feels like it shows that CGI can look GREAT in a TV series (and RWBY, to an extent).

Avatar image for sethmode
#10 Posted by SethMode (2019 posts) -

@octaslash: I wasn't super familiar with how Netflix handled this stuff, so that's good to hear! Hopefully it means the wait won't be too long because it feels like what's available now just scratches the surface.

Agreed with most everyone about the animation, it took some getting used to. For me, it felt oddly frame-y at times that I had trouble ignoring. In general, the character design and world look great, I'm just always going to be a sucker for the more hand-drawn look of something like the Venture Bros.

Avatar image for almostswedish
#11 Posted by AlmostSwedish (949 posts) -

I binged it on my way to and from school. I really liked it, and 90% of the time the animation stuff generally works out very well. I think it's the smaller movements that look a bit awkward, but when a lot of stuff is going on it looks great.

Avatar image for ripelivejam
#12 Posted by ripelivejam (13188 posts) -

Shit, I didn't know this existed and now I need it. You had me at Avatar.

Avatar image for frodobaggins
#13 Posted by FrodoBaggins (2067 posts) -

Watched the first episode, really liked it. Yeah the animation takes some getting used to but the story and setting is sooooo up my street.

Avatar image for personandstuff
#14 Posted by personandstuff (648 posts) -

I should really check out this show.

Hi Danika. I know you're reading this. I really like the pictures of your cats that you post on Twitter.

Avatar image for merxworx01
#15 Posted by MerxWorx01 (862 posts) -

Been meaning to see this ever since Danika announce she was working on it. Maybe this will be the project that sates her feet ambitions. I hear dragons are big and they got feet(four to be exact).

Avatar image for cubidog
#16 Edited by cubidog (96 posts) -

I watched the first 3 episodes and so far I have to say I'm not that into it. I honestly wish that I didn't know that anybody who worked Avatar was working on this because I am just going to compare it to that show, which is unfair because that show is probably the single best piece of fiction ever created and nothing will ever compare to it.

So far the jokes aren't funny and none of the characters seem that likable yet. Having the voice actor that played Sokka also play one of the main characters in this wasn't a great idea because once again I'm just going to be thinking of Avatar. I really dislike the art style and the action scenes looked awful. I'm going to continue watching, but as of now I'm not enjoying it.

Avatar image for jonny_anonymous
#17 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (3672 posts) -

I'm am 100% with the OP on this one. Been enjoying it a whole lot.

Online
Avatar image for meltac
#18 Posted by Meltac (2023 posts) -

@cubidog: never seen it, but is it really THAT good?

Avatar image for wandrecanada
#19 Posted by Wandrecanada (1011 posts) -

It's a good show in everything except for the whole "frame drop" style. They say it was by design but it just looks like their rendering software was hitching, especially during the slower scenes. It feels like early tech RWBY where characters sometimes looked overly stiff when moving during slow sequences.

Otherwise the show seems engaging enough. While no one will ever replicate the original Avatar this is probably as close as we're going to get to having something new from that creative team for the foreseeable future. I'm happy with what they're selling.

Avatar image for genericbrotagonist
#20 Edited by GenericBrotagonist (448 posts) -

@cubidog: I think you might be looking at Avatar with some rose colored glasses. Don't get me wrong, it's fantastic, but its jokes were just as cheesy (which made them great) and it took almost the whole first season to find its groove.

Avatar image for oodli
#21 Posted by Oodli (246 posts) -

@genericbrotagonist: I don't know, I might have a bias since I re-watch it every couple of years, but Sokka from Avatar still makes me laugh regularly.

You are right that it took it a season until everything clicked so I expect it to just get better going forward.

Avatar image for cubidog
#22 Posted by cubidog (96 posts) -

@meltac: Yes. I love that show more than anything

Avatar image for cubidog
#23 Posted by cubidog (96 posts) -

@genericbrotagonist: The jokes in Avatar weren't laugh out loud funny for the most part, but they weren't making me dislike the show like the jokes so far in this show. I still love the 1st season to this day so I don't really agree with you on the show taking a season to find its groove. Hell my dad enjoyed watching it and he doesn't enjoy cartoons for the most part so that is saying something.

Avatar image for ripelivejam
#24 Edited by ripelivejam (13188 posts) -

Agreed that A:TLA is IMO one of the most meticiously well crafted shows/plotlines ever, and that's coming from someone who experienced it in their possibly over twenties. :D Still mystified how m. night could have fucked up something so easy so royally.

Just happy he never got his grubby mitts on Toph.

Avatar image for big_denim
#25 Posted by Big_Denim (840 posts) -

@sethmode: The point of the thread COULD be to serve as a recommendation to other duders, such as myself. I think I'll be checking it out after hearing you sing it's praises. Cheers, duder!

Pretty much this. I somehow hadn't ever seen or heard of this before. Having read your recommendation and a bit more about this show, I will certainly be watching it this weekend.

Thanks duder!

Avatar image for sethmode
#26 Posted by SethMode (2019 posts) -

Well, I'm really glad this thread reminded some and introduced others!

Avatar image for theflamingo352
#27 Posted by TheFlamingo352 (350 posts) -

If I didn't like the first episode that much, should I power through? I love Avatar, and this new season is only a couple episodes, but the first episode was pretty mediocre and I don't wanna watch another hour of TV that just reminds me of what it's not.

Avatar image for sethmode
#28 Posted by SethMode (2019 posts) -

@theflamingo352: Well, they're only 25 minute(ish) episodes (so at least not an hour) and I do think that things pick up pretty quickly. I wasn't in love with it after the first episode myself, but I think I liked it more than you. It's definitely not the same thing as Avatar, but a lot of what I found charming about Avatar I personally find charming about this. The biggest negative I had once I finished the 9 episodes was that it felt like it was really getting somewhere just as the season ended.

Avatar image for marcsman
#29 Posted by Marcsman (3823 posts) -

2 episodes in and I'm hooked like a big mouth bass.