@skullomania: They also don't age in The Simpsons, but death in Dragonball isn't permament and not even an issue. Souls seem to have a jolly good time in that universe.
The Simpsons as a series is by far less realistic than Dragonball is as a whole. My main argument would be that The Simpsons doesn't showcase personal and individual growth at all. Furthermore a series such as The Simpsons is always staged in a similar way since due to its episodic nature, personal growth and realization isn't character dependant and is only there to the viewer to reflect their own reality with the series. Dragonball is way more nuanced and personal to its characters as the characters are always confronting the extreme.
In other words, the characters in The Simpsons literally never change their ways, either physiological or psychological for the sake of its timeless metaphorical impact of modern culture. While this works for a couple of times it does become tiresome and unrealistic pretty fast. The result of this is that the main cast of characters become reduced to mere caricatures and thus become devoid of any sort of soul in the long run.
Look at Dragonball Super, which basically turns this set of tropes around to become funny playful and original, while being way less serious in tone and what it tries to tell to the viewer. You can also for sure argue that even Goku alone has more personality than the entirety of the cast that has ever appeared on The Simpsons.
I also would say that Goku is a better dad, as hes actually actively caring about his family in a larger way than Homer does or ever did. Due to the nature of shounen anime and the Dragonball universe things would be worse without Goku around while Homer Simpson basically is a walking catastrophe (for the sake of showcasing the caricature of an american family man) without even knowing about it, though its still an important comedic representation of american family values.
So my vote goes for Homer Simpson for being (slightly) worse than Goku.
EDIT: Some good counter arguments in this thread. I always felt like The Simpsons episodic structure is too erratic to really showcase Homers nature in a proper way, but thats also partially because way to many writers worked on that perticular character.
Log in to comment