I'm really torn about this. Maybe someone can help - I'll play advocate of the devil here. Please bear with me as I try to coherently write down my internal struggle in an attempt to resolve the cognitive dissonance.
I'm watching gameplay of Breath of the Wild and I am assessing it objectively. Like a businessman trying to gauge how valuable a new investment is.
What I see is a semi-polished game with outdated mechanics, a lack of NPC voice acting, a dodgy framerate and an interesting world which does seem to be hindered somewhat by its own mechanics. The visuals look stunning in terms of art in some place, and incredibly bland and gray (and empty) in others. In essence it looks like a solid 7/10 game with some (outdated) shine to it. I wouldn't buy this game if I saw video's of it - that's my conclusion. Perhaps if it got rave reviews and was on discount for $30. So... there's my rather harsh introduction. Stick with me.
Now. I am also a huge Zelda fan. I've played through ALTTP and OOT perhaps a combined total of 20 times. I'm also hugely nostalgic for Majora's Mask for its quirky game world even though the actual game I didn't like so much for its time-based mechanics. For me, Zelda is synonymous with farm fuzzy feeling and unadulterated hype. A new Zelda game is always exciting - even if I've not owned a Nintendo console since Gamecube I've always followed the latest Zelda titles as they are a benchmark for the quality of the system for me.
Back to the analogy of the businessman. I'm 30 now. I've become more critical of the money I spend on things; on the time I spend on things and through the years I got better at controlling my inner hypetrain. In fact, Breath of the Wild is the first game which has me considering the purchase of a console (X360) since Red Dead Redemption. So what are we talking about here? We're talking about smacking down €330,- for a console which I might never use again after finishing the game (not because it's a bad console, but because this is who I am - a PC gamer who hasn't been drawn to a console game since Red Dead Redemption. You'll make up arguments and speak of Mario Kart or Mario Odyssey or other games. I'll just sit there and shrug). On top of that I'll spend €60,- on a game which I might play occasionally, but probably won't.
Consider that money is no problem - I've got that cash lying around and I'll spend it in a heartbeat. It'll hurt me to spend it as I'm not rich but I'm just saying that - yes - for me there could be a game worth €400,- (in other words: I'm eradicating the factor that I'll never turn on my Switch again - and that this fact might pose a road block - from this discussion).
Do I buy the Switch and BOTW? Here is my line of thought and although this is becoming a lengthy question I'll request your attention a little bit longer.
1. It's Zelda and my inner hype train is running at full speed.
2. It looks like Zelda - train is increasing speed still.
3. But my warm fuzzy feelings are mostly based around the Master Sword. And a Hylian shield. And a narrative involving a princess. And dungeons containing new tools and weapons.
4. Hype train just halved its speed.
5. But look at that open world... that's been everything my imagination made Hyrule field out to be since the original Zelda! (hype train speeds up again).
6. But actually...when I look at videos and objectively strip away the names and the typical Nintendo look and feel... it doesn't look like Zelda. Not really. It looks like the rather bland open world game described in my rather harsh introduction.
I'm a rational being. I'm analytical, nostalgic and in spite of this I can still be fun to talk to at parties. I'm just not sure if I like the idea of Breath of the Wild.
So my final question would be: which other rational being, who has already taken the plunge, can help me out here? How much Zelda is actually in this game if you strip away what I (and we as a game community?) have built up internally in our nostalgic minds? Will I play BOTW and have my warm fuzzy feelings comforted? Or will I be riding on nostalgia and longing for 'permanent gear', dungeons, an A-Z narrative, etc?
Would love to hear some thoughts, and forgive me for the long run-up and the black/white language.
Log in to comment