Big Boy Season: The Design of Titanfall 2

Avatar image for gamer_152
gamer_152

14810

Forum Posts

73592

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 71

User Lists: 6

Edited By gamer_152  Moderator

Note: The following article contains major spoilers for Titanfall 2.

No Caption Provided

Titanfall 2 is the best shooter I've played in years. Respawn Entertainment's military sci-fi binds together threads of silky movement, and intense, ever-changing combat to create a fabric of uninterrupted flow. A rich buffet of player actions means that wherever you are on the map, whichever items you have at your disposal, there are almost always multiple navigational and strategic options on the table. Whether you're a Titan: one of the oil-stained mechs that can tear through a squad without breaking a sweat, or a pilot: the swift, acrobatic soldiers on the ground, the play remains compelling.

No Caption Provided

Most of the slick features that Titanfall 2 implements, it didn't invent, but that doesn't mean they contribute anything less to the experience. It's typically not the most original games that are the most popular, but the titles that have sat back and watched the medium's emerging trends. They take some time to chew over which concepts and approaches worked for other devs and which didn't, panning out the silt and leaving only the gold. There's a balance to be struck between imitation and invention; just crib mechanics from other games and audiences will ask where the originality is. However, by toeing the line between the novel and the known, Titanfall made a name for itself.

Here, I'm going to be talking about a lot of mechanics that don't originate in Titanfall 2, but I'm not interested in recording a history of first-person shooters; I want to talk about why Titanfall 2's design invigorates. Here are a few design decisions Respawn made that paid off with interest:

1. Suitable Story

Single-player modes in AAA are typically a breeding ground for ludonarrative dissonance. Stories tell us that war is hell while play tells us that war is a fun way to chill out after work. A character may die, and the tone of the writing will darken, but the mechanics will remain just as focused on the upbeat. Most action gameplay is aiming to fill the audience up with empowerment and a sense of mastery, and so a complementary story for that play should be about the same emotions; Titanfall 2 contains that breed of story. Sure, it takes place during a military conflict and it'll never entirely rid itself of the seriousness that brings, but it's as light a take on the topic as you're going to get.

No Caption Provided

Instead of trying to be a Band of Brothers or a Black Hawk Down, Titanfall 2 is more like if Dreamworks had a creative hand in CoD, and I mean that as a compliment. The story follows Jack Cooper, an optimistic neophyte who dreams of becoming a Titan pilot. When his commanding officer is wiped out in a freak accident, he's the only one left to take over his robot ally: BT-7274. It takes a few dances with the antagonists for Jack to find his feet as an operator, but by the time that the Militia recovers him and BT, they are so in sync with each other that Jack's the only one that can lead the Titan into enemy territory and save the day.

Titanfall 2's story isn't Mariana deep, but you can see how suitable it is for an action game: Jack and BT's motivation, progress, and relationship involve improving their combat proficiency which is also what motivates us as the player and is how we measure our progress. The game aligns our interests and our journey with those of the characters. Cooper suddenly having to take on a mission above his station also helps explain why we might still be feeling out our tools even though we're playing a soldier in active duty.

2. Level-Exclusive Mechanics

No Caption Provided

Discussions about matching play to story pop up fairly frequently, but in the broader gaming community, we don't talk enough about matching play to the environment. In most of Titanfall 2's stages, the nature of the spaces we occupy is embodied in mechanics unique to the current level. When we're on an assembly line, we must platform between the conveyer belts and dodge heat elements and robotic arms. In the experimental research facility, we get a clicker that allows us to flash back and forth through time. In the construction site, we can swivel cranes around to create paths between surfaces.

Settings aren't just more rooms in which to shoot troops; we interact with them on a functional and thematic level. And because new styles of play are baked into each level, those stages all have individual personalities. Changing up the play level by level also keeps it from stagnating, and appropriately, the narrative apex of the game is the moment where the protagonist is the most passionate about his battle. After the IMC string up BT and take an axe to his body, BT gives us a parting gift: the Smart Pistol. It's a homing handgun that can dispense a soldier with a single shot. We immediately use it for vengeance, sprinting and sliding through the IMC base, laying waste to them at incredible speed.

No Caption Provided

There are more shooter campaigns than I can count that treat their story mode as a PvE version of the multiplayer. Titanfall 2 goes further, thinking about what forms of play could only happen when it has a sole audience member. Having the player blow up a whole armoury of mechs in a row or spontaneously travel through time would be exceedingly tricky to pull off in a competitive environment, but such features fit like peas in the pod of the campaign mode.

3. Power Weapon Distribution

Titanfall 2's multiplayer might leave me closer to the edge of my seat than even the single-player. How Respawn slots the Titans in alongside the foot soldiers is particularly inspired. Essentially, what they do with these walking fortresses is rethink how a shooter should distribute power weapons and how those weapons might operate. Since the antique days of the medium, arena shooters have spawned devastating guns around the map and let players collect them on a first-come, first-served basis. There can be an element of skill in obtaining power weapons that way; mini-battles can break out around the pedestals to ordain who gets the Railgun or the Rocket Launcher. However, this technique often awards weapons randomly, doling them out to whoever happens to be in the right place at the right time.

No Caption Provided

Halo 5 is one example of a game that improved on this system by feeding players data on when and where the power weapons were going to teleport in. Spartans would all rush for these hotspots at the same time, and acquisition of the toys more often came down to whether you could survive the resulting melee. Modern Warfare had its own solution that didn't bring people together for controller-shaking conflicts, but did encourage players to move more freely around the map and awarded items based on general performance. Killstreaks and deathstreaks dispense boosts and weaponry to players, wherever they are, based on how many times they've killed other players without dying or how many times they've died without killing another player.

However, all the above methods leave collecting high-end firearms as a zero-sum game. Most players aren't going to get a chance with the Minigun or the Fuel Road Cannon because you've got just a few weapons to go around a whole lobby's worth of soldiers. This may not seem to be the case with Modern Warfare as all players have personal counters that build to them nabbing their prizes. However, when one player's kill resets another player's killstreak counter, a lot of people aren't going to get a look-in on any of the most fun items the game has to offer. This is particularly true because sometimes players can use power weapons to create a feedback loop where they are always in the prime position to collect more power weapons.

No Caption Provided

In Titanfall 2, the Titans are effectively power weapons and boosts. They're dressed in high calibre guns, lasers, and munitions launchers and bless you with extreme endurance. In matches, every player gets to wrap their fist around a power weapon because we all have individual meters that tick towards titanfall over time. The systems still respect our talent in that we can accelerate our charge towards titanfall by blowing away opponents, but because other players can't stop us earning our power weapon by killing us, some time in the Titan is guaranteed. Usually, quite a lot of time, given that the mechs have plenty of health. In another multiplayer, the Titan might constitute an unfair advantage, but when these machines are highly available to all fighters, the playing field remains level. You also can't use your Titan to steamroll other players to get your next power weapon. Your kills in the Titan fill a meter that progresses towards you earning a special attack, not another Titan.

4. Player-Titan Balance

Sometimes, we get halfway through a match of a multiplayer game, and we feel like we're sleepwalking through the same routes and routines. Titanfall transitions us between the pilot and Titan modes every few minutes, and this keeps the excitement from souring. It works because embarking into a Titan in this game changes a lot more than picking up a power weapon does in an orthodox FPS. In other games, you might sling a Chaingun over your shoulder and alter your mode of fire through it, but your movement model and other abilities such as grenade lobbing and sprinting will likely remain untouched. In Titanfall, when you switch into a mech, the ceiling on your top speed comes down, but your health and size bloom. Your tactical ability, sprint, grenade, jump, wall-run, and original weapon set are suspended, but in their place, you get a beefier main gun, an ordinance weapon, a defensive ability, a tactical ability, a boost, and a special.

No Caption Provided

With the Titans crashing onto the dirt more frequently than typical power weapons, the complete transformation of anyone who nestles into a Titan's cockpit is necessary to keep the contests balanced. Balance manifests through trade-offs, and when you jump into or out of a Titan, you trade a lot. In many games, the power weapons are superior to the regular kit. Even if they require a deft hand to operate correctly, a skilled player with a Rocket Launcher or Sniper Rifle, will, on average, outshoot an experienced player with a Pistol or Machine Gun. In Titanfall, a Titan isn't strictly better than a pilot; they each have their fortes.

A lot of interactive entertainment pits fast, strong characters, against slow, weak ones, but the difference between the pilots and the Titans is more nuanced than that. Humans, on their own, aren't just faster than the Titans and capable of using traversal mechanics; they possess Anti-Titan weapons and can fit into the nooks and crannies that Titans can't. Those Anti-Titan guns are slow-acting, but you get a dynamic where a Titan will assuredly reduce a pilot standing in the middle of the street to a cloud of red spray, but a pilot can safely peek in and out of cover, making glancing blows at those metal giants. Mechs may rule the open spaces and make their drivers feel invincible, but as pilots, we have a quiet ferocity and can soar through the maps like birds. There are so many FPSs where the default loadout feels pretty good to rock, but we're all waiting with bated breath for those Rocket Launcher moments. The developer has to be conservative with giving you those bursts of formidability for the sake of balancing. Someone at Respawn thought "What if the game just felt empowering at all times?". Whether you're grappling to the tops of buildings and popping off an Assault Rifle or sitting in twenty-four-foot tall impenetrable power armour, you feel like you're in charge of the map, and you get to because the Titans and pilots are appropriately matched and have unique strengths.

5. A Battlefield Atmosphere

No Caption Provided

One revelatory discovery that the Battlefield series made was that when you unleash a lot of vehicles into the arena of combat, their sheer size and thunderous armaments create the atmosphere of a warzone. It's particularly effective because we know the bombings and plumes of dirt are not stage effects; they're part of the organic scrimmages of the match. Titanfall replicates that effect by allowing up to ten Titans on the map at a time, all unloading lasers, rockets, and much more. The appearance of AI soldiers on the field further stokes the fires of war. They take the environments from feeling like empty virtual arenas expressly designed for players to sites of actual armies clashing.

The arrival of Titans and troops wouldn't feel as rousing if it weren't for them dropping in from the sky, the resulting shockwave reverberating across the map. In a rare touch for the genre, Titanfall also understands that as each match is an action scene, it should build in extremity and scale as time goes on; you'd never see a scene in a film where the intensity stays at a constant level the entire time because that's not as thrilling. In Titanfall 2, every team starts without any Titans and are reinforced by lowly grunts. As time goes on, more and more players become able to use their boosts, and later, call down their mechs. Soon, everyone has landed a Titan at least once, and robotic soldiers storm onto the map to back the teams up. By the end of the match, aggressive "Reaper" bots with anti-Titan weapons stomp across the terrain.

No Caption Provided

Such texture in the play is only possible through extraordinary balancing. When players are holding roughly the same cards, there's fewer gaps in ability that the designer needs to account for. However, in Titanfall, pilots can mix and match any part of their loadout, and there are seven different Titans, each with a multitude of unique powers. That's a lot of differences between players that most developers couldn't manage, but through some combination of resources and expertise, Respawn keeps them all in equilibrium.

6. Multiple Metrics of Success

In classical games, "succeeding" is synonymous with winning which can leave a lot of players feeling left out. At least 50% will come away with a loss on their record and not much else to show for it. Over roughly the past fifteen years, many video games have attempted to rectify this by including more definitions of success. Mostly, they do this through acknowledging individual success in addition to team success. Maybe your side didn't walk away with the gold, but you were the Most Valuable Player, or you racked up a high K/D. Overwatch is an example of modern games being very forthcoming with such statistics, announcing who did the most healing, the most damage, got the play of the game, etc. Even in a modern multiplayer game where you faltered in all categories, you probably still contributed to a persistent metric of success like your XP, loot, or achievements. Titanfall 2 incorporates many of the boilerplate indicators of personal success such as listing the top 3 players for each match, featuring levelling systems, and including unlockables. However, this title goes to particular lengths to deemphasise the outcome of the competition, providing more reasons to feel like you're doing swimmingly in yourself.

No Caption Provided

For example, its post-match scoreboards don't display how many times you died in a match, only the number of kills you achieved. It makes players feel good about their performance by showing them only a measurement of success and not one of failure. Audience members might otherwise feel dejected because stats like their kill numbers don't stack up to their opponents', but Titanfall 2 keeps all profiles private, meaning that players can't make that comparison and also aren't stressed out by social judgement of their long-term stats. Of course, users often still want some competitive metric, so there is an increasing number of games like Titanfall 2 getting released which compare current player stats to their previous records rather than to the stats of the player base overall. E.g. Some systems won't identify how many headshots you got in that match compared to the rest of your team; they check how many headshots you got compared to your personal best. Again, Overwatch loves doing this.

Titanfall 2 follows this approach by tracking the number of times you placed in the top 3 and were MVP as hard integers rather than percentages. Additionally, it features K/D and "Time Alive" graphs that don't use a 0 as a baseline, but instead, use your average in each category. Your competition isn't all Titanfall 2 players as much as it is the past you, and if you play regularly, you should keep surpassing past you with a reliability that you couldn't beat other players. Titanfall's developers also find a way to keep everyone feeling like they have a boastworthy K/D. In most games, K/D is zero-sum. For one player's K/D to increase, another's must fall because a kill on one person's sheet is a death on another's. This means that a negative kill-to-death ratio tars about half of the players. Titanfall 2 avoids this shaming by including kills on the AI in the K/D ratio. Soldier AI drops at the sight of a gun so that most players will come away with a K/D in the black. No debt of deaths has to appear on anyone's permanent log because all those failures are soaked up by computer-controlled characters.

No Caption Provided

Titanfall 2 filling out the battlefield with break-away AI fighters also means that even if the player can't find opponents on the map right now, or else, isn't skilled enough to fell them, they can still best targets and increase the team's score. In another sense, the minions are something to do between the skirmishes with other players; they're like the coins in a Mario game that thread you along to the next platforming section or enemy. I stress that Titanfall 2's tilt towards internal comparisons of success over external comparisons isn't one that's going to please all users. Players who go hardcore into the sport of these games will often want to see their dominance of the competition rewarded with astronomical K/Ds, high MVP percentages, etc. They also crave stats as guiding stars by which they can tactically navigate. Titanfall is not "improving" how winning is framed but is providing a framing that pleases the masses more than the pros.

Finally, each game of Titanfall 2 offers losers a reprieve through the epilogue wherein fighters are capped at one life and must escape to a dropship while the opposing team tries to intercept them. You don't always evacuate, and so sometimes experience a kind of "double loss" where you can't get the most points and can't leave the hot zone. However, with the epilogue, a good player on a bad team might not be able to win the match, but they can often evacuate, and nothing is lost if they can't. Overall, the feature gives you more conciliatory exits to matches.

No Caption Provided

The epilogue is also a burst of tension that tops off the play. Shooters that give us a single life like PUBG and Counter-Strike are revered by their fans due to their high stakes. But for their critics, an inability to respawn is excessively harsh and a lot of time spectating while everyone else continues to participate bores them to tears. The epilogue ushers in all the suspense of the one-shot shooter without severely punishing anyone who dies: those players don't lose the round, they just don't get to extract. And because the epilogue is only a phase of play that caps off a regular match, participants aren't going to spend round after round sitting on the bench while better shots do all the work.

Conclusion

There's an old saying that if it isn't broke, don't fix it, perhaps popularised by rashes of failed experiments in upgrading various systems. However, progress in any field is about improving on the acceptable as much as erasing the unacceptable, and Titanfall 2 is exemplary of that. The FPSs that Titanfall 2 learns from were sublime, and yet, it was still worth Respawn thinking about how they could further distil the positives of those experiences and drain them of the negative. For their efforts, the studio got a game where the single-player neatly aligns play with environment and story, and the multiplayer empowers more equally and more frequently. Thanks for reading.

Avatar image for nateandrews
nateandrews

131

Forum Posts

7922

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 11

User Lists: 8

#1  Edited By nateandrews

Excellent write-up. One of the things that makes Titanfall 2 stand out to me is how out-of-time it feels nowadays. It missed the boat on loot boxes, battle passes, and pervasive microtransactions, instead settling for direct purchase of certain cosmetic items. And there was no extensive roadmap, for better or worse. Titanfall 2 was just Titanfall 2. It harkened back to the way games were last gen, where you'd get a single player campaign and a multiplayer and hopefully both were great. Some of my favorite games this gen are multiplayer titles that have gotten years of support, but there's something admirable about how Titanfall 2 just played it straight and to the point. It also avoided the weekly controversies, apologies, and subreddit meltdowns that seem to accompany every single multiplayer game these days. I have nothing but the most positive feelings for this game.

Avatar image for gamer_152
gamer_152

14810

Forum Posts

73592

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 71

User Lists: 6

#2 gamer_152  Moderator

@nateandrews: Thank you, and I agree, the game feels very self-complete, and I wish more titles did these days. Long-term roadmaps may result in more content in games in the long-run, but they often accompany games that come out lacking in features and content, and they're very difficult for AAA studios to stick to. It's rare to find a blockbuster video game that doesn't go for the most sprawling scope possible, but Titanfall 2 doesn't, and that means it gets to focus in on balancing and varying the relatively small number of areas and features it does have. It is worth noting that a lot of the reason those games with huge roadmaps go wrong is because they're part-RPG and that's a format that requires the production of a lot of quests and areas and loot. By being a pretty straight shooter, Titfanfall 2 can just survive on its core loop, because in a game based heavily on competition, if that core loop is good enough, then you can stay playing with the same maps and guns over and over, and it won't get boring.

Avatar image for philipduck
PhilipDuck

768

Forum Posts

19

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Great read and totally agree, one of the stand out games of the generation. Need to give this another play through some time soon!

Avatar image for gamer_152
gamer_152

14810

Forum Posts

73592

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 71

User Lists: 6

#4 gamer_152  Moderator

@philipduck: Thank you, I appreciate it. It's a good replay: the mechanics change about enough, the core loop never gets boring, and that campaign doesn't overstay its welcome.

Avatar image for pewpewphil
pewpewphil

74

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#5  Edited By pewpewphil

Excellent post on one of the best shooters this generation has to offer. I've loved the games Respawn has put out thus far, and am currently playing a ton in Apex Legends. I would like to see how well I transition back into Titanfall 2 after being away from all the pilot and Titan mechanics. Even though Apex is much more accessible, it is a lesser game compared to Titanfall2.

I do miss how well crafted Titanfall 2 felt now that I think about (both online and single player ). Maps were well made, weapons all felt great to use, and using abilities was awesome. Titans felt powerful to use but when facing against one ( on foot or in a titan), never too aggravating. One thing in multiplayer was that I had no down time, there was some form of evolving action in the map, without altering the map. I do believe Respawn put their best foot forward with Titanfall 2 and it really does show.

Avatar image for nateandrews
nateandrews

131

Forum Posts

7922

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 11

User Lists: 8

@pewpewphil: It's been fun going back to Titanfall 2 after Apex Legends and comparing how the weapons that are in both games feel. I really wish the L-Star wasn't a supply drop weapon because it's my favorite in Titanfall 2.

One thing I think about often in regards to Titanfall 2 is whether or not it was a mistake to not have grapple be an ability everyone has at all times. I simply cannot imagine playing that game without it. It feels so awesome swinging myself across great distances and getting airborne kills. None of the other abilities even come close to being this interesting and dynamic for me.

Avatar image for gamer_152
gamer_152

14810

Forum Posts

73592

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 71

User Lists: 6

#7 gamer_152  Moderator

@pewpewphil: Thank you very much. For what it's worth, I've found it easy to jump back into Titanfall 2 after being away for a while, but I play shooters semi-regularly so that probably helps.

@nateandrews: I agree, I've never dropped the grapple. I'm very into that kind of freeing movement in an action game.

Avatar image for dogpostsonly
Dogpostsonly

22

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

This was a great write up, really helped me gain a better understanding at what Titanfall 2 is and does and might have given me that boost to finally pick up and play it.

Avatar image for gamer_152
gamer_152

14810

Forum Posts

73592

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 71

User Lists: 6

#9 gamer_152  Moderator

@dogpostsonly: Thank you very much. You probably wouldn't be surprised to learn that I'd recommend the game, but I understand that everyone has a different financial situation and there are cheaper games.

Avatar image for jam13
Jam13

35

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@gamer_152 Thanks for the comprehensive and well thought-through write-up. Reminds me of the great times I had with this game a few years back. I'd fallen off competitive online shooters after the original Modern Warfare, so I was surprised when Titanfall 2's multiplayer gripped me as much as it did (I bought it primarily for the much lauded campaign). To your point in the write-up: the way the game's metrics bring a player's successes to the fore, whilst sidelining failure is a key part of its success in keeping someone playing. Even early on if you're getting you arse handed to you you're shown signs of improvement to motivate you, rather than being deflated that a player on the other team (or your own) put in a far better performance. If it weren't for that, I'd never have put in the time I needed to to be able to be competitive.

I think the point re the AI combatants on the field is key - even if I couldn't take on the best players on the map, shooting down some increasingly tough AI enemies meant I was adding to the score, even if it didn't require the same skill as taking down a human opponent.

Avatar image for gamer_152
gamer_152

14810

Forum Posts

73592

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 71

User Lists: 6

#11 gamer_152  Moderator

@jam13: I appreciate the praise. I think generally, just as CoD 4 was seen as revolutionising the more traditional FPS formula, a lot of people felt Titanfall was taking the next big step after Modern Warfare. Of course, it is possible to get into matches in Titanfall 2 where you're just mismatched against a much tougher opponent and that can suck, even with all the emphasis on your successes. However, I believe that the player base of Titanfall 2 is as healthy as it is today because when a lot of people jumped in, they didn't see failure over and over until they "got good", they received a bunch of rewards for their play, and they saw a lot of messages and stats about what they did right. Those kinds of design choices don't just make your game more fun for casual players, they make the multiplayer last longer for everyone.