Remakes of old maps have begun. The game isn't even out yet and the most played map in Halo 3 has already been remade.  What other maps do you want remade? What map you care so much that you'll actually do the remake?
  

I hated that map. 
 
 
Just sayin'.

" I hated that map.    Just sayin'. "

That's guardian alright. Looks good.

Sweet. I'm starting to get hyped at Reach. They really did improve everything from the beta. Playing it at PAX was great. 
 
I really want a remake of The Pit.

" I really want a remake of The Pit. "

It wasn't good for 1v1 or 4v4, it was one of my least favorite Halo maps of all time. 
 
The remake of it wasn't that great, it could have been done better and more like the normal one, seems kinda thrown together and lazy.

Doesn't look that accurate.

Remaking any of the Halo 3 maps seems a sort of dicey decision, to me, from a fan standpoint. But, as Jeff said, Bungie is trying to ensure this is the definitive Halo game that people will be playing as long as Halo is relevant, so this decision makes a lot of sense.  
 
I'm sure each rebooted map is going to get this sort of reaction, since most of the fan favorites have already seen their own personal resurrections in previous Halo installments, though I wouldn't be at all shocked to see a formal Blood Gulch revival somewhere along the line.  

A lot bigger and less professional looking of course but that's pretty neat.

weird dashboard....also needs more foilage

The vid starts out with my favorite Halo song so i automatically love this vid. 
  
 Peril from the Halo 2 OST.

I suddenly got really excited for it. I even went out today and pre-order it even when I told myself I wasn't getting it when it comes out.

It looks off at certain parts but cant wait to play this game.

i want a cold storage remake please!

I want Standoff to be in it. I freaking love that map. And Blood Gulch of course, but I thought that was actually coming. 
 
PS Is that what a modded 360 looks like on the dashboard?

Orbital, best map on Halo 3.

"weird dashboard....also needs more foilage "

I was never crazy about Guardian. It was alright.

Make The Pit.

Meh, a straight Guardian remake isn't something I'm interested in playing (though I would be interested to see how the map flows if the two short lifts that connect bottom green to Camo and bottom blue to Snipe were replaced by walkways that would allow players to travel in both directions). Actually, none of the Halo 3 maps are worth remaking IMO. The best map in the game, The Pit, is decidedly mediocre compared to the best of the first two games. I'd rather play creatively designed original maps than remakes of maps that weren't great to begin with.

" Meh, a straight Guardian remake isn't something I'm interested in playing (though I would be interested to see how the map flows if the two short lifts that connect bottom green to Camo and bottom blue to Snipe were replaced by walkways that would allow players to travel in both directions). Actually, none of the Halo 3 maps are worth remaking IMO. The best map in the game, The Pit, is decidedly mediocre compared to the best of the first two games. I'd rather play creatively designed original maps than remakes of maps that weren't great to begin with. "

"  @DystopiaX: After using Forge 2.0 for myself and creating some quick and basic maps, I can say without equivocation that talented Forgers will be able to create a flawless remake of Lockout within the first week of the game's release. Bungie really did a good job improving Forge; it's not perfect, but it is definitely good enough to accurately remake all but the most complicated maps from previous Halo games.  Also, I don't think Prisoner would work well in Reach. To be honest, it almost didn't work in Halo 1. While I like the potential that Reach has to be a skillful game, it certainly isn't fast enough in either movement speed or kill times under default settings to benefit from the vertical geometry of Prisoner. The team who gains top control would have a vice grip on the entire map given the relatively slow kill speed of the DMR (see also: Sword Base), and most Armor Abilities, especially Jetpack, would destroy the traditional flow of the map. Hang 'Em High could work well, though. Unlike Priz, which really only had Camo and Rockets to encourage players to abandon top control, Hang 'Em had a bunch of different items to control (2 Camos, Snipe, Rockets, OS, PR, Shotgun) as well as a much less dominating power position. I still don't think Armor Abilities would improve the way the map plays, but things like Jetpack and Sprint certainly wouldn't be as game breaking on HeH as they would be on Prisoner.   Personally, I think the two best Halo 1 maps to remake for Reach would be Wizard and Rat Race. "

That is pretty awesome.
Hang em high please.

"  @DystopiaX: Yeah, the Sanctuary remake could use some cleaning up. It's very easy to get on top of the Sniper hut in either base; just two quick jumps and you're on top of the map. That can be fixed easily with a soft or hard killzone, though. The other Forge World maps are a bit hit or miss. Hemorrhage (Blood Gulch) and Pinnacle (Ascension) are both perfect remakes; definitely worthy of being listed as official maps. Paradiso and The Cage are alright, but they definitely feel like Forge maps. The good news is, though, that those maps in no way represent the best of what Forge World or Forge 2.0 are capable of producing. I never built anything noteworthy with Forge in Halo 3 (not even an Infection map or a race track), but I was able to crank out a pretty respectable Warlock remake in less than 2 hours in Forge World.   Also, for what it's worth, I think the Reach maps are definitely a step above Halo 3's maps in terms of design. Except for Sword Base, which I despise for its linearity and lack of flanking routes, the maps are great. Boardwalk is everything that Narrows should have been, and Countdown is like Construct but with more routes to the top. I'm sure you remember Powerhouse and Boneyard from the beta; they're both pretty solid. Zealot is fantastic if restricted to the bottom two levels, though I can't say I'm too fond of the zero-G space tier. Reflection is an improvement on Ivory Tower thanks to some subtle yet positive geometry changes. Can't comment on Spire, as I haven't played it in a Big Team/Invasion setting. So while there are only 8 non-Forge maps on the disc, I'll take 8 (well, 7 if we're not counting Sword Base) well-designed, flexible, replayable maps and one incredibly versatile canvas over 11 middling to terrible maps that include such travesties of game design as Epitaph and Snowbound.  Re: weapon damage. It is impossible to make the DMR even a 4 shot kill without breaking several key weapons, including Rockets and Sniper. Sadly, I don't think a Prisoner remake could work in Reach the way it did in H1 no matter the settings. 120% Speed is pretty great though -- snappy strafing with no ice skating. Feels just like Halo 2's movement speed, and it's the default setting for Slayer Pro so we'll probably see a lot of it in Arena playlists.  I too missed Wizard/Warlock in Halo 3. Thankfully, it's easy to recreate in Forge World and works even better than it ever could have in H3 because the DMR is so much more of a cross-map threat than the woeful H3 BR. Base to base shooting is actually possible on the map in Reach and Bungie has fixed the teleporters since Halo 3, so it's just as frantic and fast-paced as it was in Halo 2. "

" @MrMuscle: It was a modded xbox 360. They had Reach for a while so they are cranking out maps "

" I want Standoff to be in it. I freaking love that map. And Blood Gulch of course, but I thought that was actually coming.  PS Is that what a modded 360 looks like on the dashboard? "

" @xyzygy said:

" I want Standoff to be in it. I freaking love that map. And Blood Gulch of course, but I thought that was actually coming.  PS Is that what a modded 360 looks like on the dashboard? "

Dude... I want a proper Boarding Action remake. "

I only liked that make in Lone Wolves, otherwise it was annoying. Pit was the best map, and valhalla.

" @DystopiaX: True there are some maps in previous games that are just better than any map that came after. Like Beaver Creek, Midship, Lockout, Warlock. These maps are the best for their respective gametypes, I'd personally play them rather than original maps that haven't been tested very well. But whatever Forge World seems so robust that pretty much remakes of all maps from previous games and other games like COD4 and CS will be made. "