The issue I see with Hagatha and Witch's Apprentice is that on average, "get a random Shaman spell" is much worse than "get a random Mage spell". A bunch of Shaman Spells are just absolute garbage (the 0-cost spells, Frost Shock, Ancestral Spirit, Cryostasis, Ice Fishing, Rockbiter Weapon, Windfury, Primal Talismans, Avalanche, Lesser Sapphire Spellstone) that you almost never want to get. Granted, some of those may be situationally useful (maybe you have a powerful minion out so Ancestral Spirit or Windfury has a decent target), but most of them are practically useless in most circumstances. At least Primal Fusion is rotating out of Standard.
I agree though, it may turn out that Hagatha has Lyra-like potential, where if you just spam out enough activations of Hagatha's hero power, a miracle will occur and you'll actually get enough non-worthless spells to do something. But Shaman spells fucking suuuuuuuuck when you can't choose which ones you're getting. It's one of the numerous reasons that Runespear is so bad.
Houndmaster Shaw is an interesting fixed Warsong Commander. I'm still amazed that Blizzard chose to obliterate Warsong Commander instead of simply giving it the Houndmaster Shaw wording. If you'll recall, they fixed the Charge spell a while ago by basically changing it to Rush. It's strange that instead of giving similar wording to Warsong Commander, they gave it this lame ability that is of no use to anyone. I don't know exactly what potential giving Rush to your minions has; both Houndmaster Shaw and Glinda Crowskin remind me of Baron Rivendare, in that they're an interesting effect, but they're so expensive that you can't play many minions alongside them under normal circumstances, so you have to play them and somehow hope that their moderately high health keeps them live an entire turn. Maybe they'll turn out great, who knows.
Rebuke is going to be pretty disgusting and I assume will somehow fit its way into Aggro Paladin decklists, as a way to protect their board once they fill it. Not sure what they'll cut for it, but it seems so good that they'll have to include it.
Log in to comment