Hey everyone. I'm considering putting up a dedicated forum post for this, but just because this thread is here: The mod team here on Giant Bomb has always taken the handling of spoilers and those who spoil things quite seriously. We are always actively monitoring topics and blogs for unmarked spoilers and spoilers in thread titles, and editing or deleting things where appropriate.
Please flag spoilers either by using the Flag button found on all posts, or by using the PM All Mods link to easily send a group PM out to every active moderator. You can always find this link in the pinned Community Rules thread. This will give you the fastest response, as usually whoever sees one of these messages from the community first will go ahead and act and handle it. Response times for high priority messages regarding things like major spoilers in thread titles are usually measured in minutes, or even seconds. We'll be watching, but a little help finding this stuff is always appreciated, and the few seconds you take out of your day to notify us about the spoiler you just saw will go a long way towards ensuring your fellow Giant Bombers aren't unnecessarily spoiled as well.
As moderators, it puts us in a position where we inevitably are forced to read spoilers for a game we care about. Whether that is because we are always reading as many topics as we can, or are scanning thread titles throughout the day, or looking at flags or PMs from the community that contain spoilers themselves, or reviewing Wiki edits or image submissions that are loaded with spoilers. Thankfully, I don't particularly care about Metal Gear Solid, so getting part or all of this game spoiled for me isn't a big deal. However - I know a few of my colleagues are big fans of this series, and I would hate to see them get unnecessarily spoiled. So, I'm going to ask you a favor and a bit of special handling when it comes to Phantom Pain spoilers:
If you are going to send us a group PM about a Metal Gear spoiler, please clearly notate in the subject line that the message contains MGS-related spoilers. For the body of the PM, if there is a way for you to describe the nature of the spoiler and where it is without actually spoiling the entire mod team in the process, please do so! For instance - you could say something like, "In this post (give link to exact post or thread) user XxSpoilerDude420xX spoils the end of MGS V." That would be highly preferable to a PM that is more like, "Some user spoils the end of MGS V by saying the world explodes and nanomachines take over." I know this is a bit of an extreme example, but trust me...it happens. You can also use spoiler tags and spoiler blocks within PMs, so I definitely encourage you to do so if you feel they are needed to report a spoiler properly. Just clearly notate in the body of your PM that you're about to discuss the spoiler in question, and mark it off with a spoiler block. That way when we review the PM as a group, the mods who are actively trying to avoid any spoilers for Metal Gear can simply leave it, and people who don't care so much about the game can review stuff like that so they don't have to.
Regarding thread titles - Spoilers in thread titles are never permitted. This is a difficult subject because different people have differing definitions on what constitutes a spoiler. We ask that when you are crafting thread titles, keep this in mind and ask yourself, "Is this something that some people would like to discover on their own about Phantom Pain?" Remember, it doesn't even necessarily have to be about the main plot of the game to be considered a spoiler for many people. It could be something like the name of a boss, the return of a character from a previous Metal Gear game that surprised you, things like that. Here is an example of what I would consider a thread title that is a minor spoiler, but a spoiler nonetheless: "Covert Mantis Badger (3rd boss) is unbeatable!" Now, the name of a boss might seem like nothing to you, but it may be a big deal to someone else. A much better option would be this instead, "The third boss is unbeatable!" This way people who have already gotten to or beaten the third boss know they can safely come into the thread and read about it or help others with their strategy, while not needlessly spoiling the name for people who haven't gotten that far yet. Please just think about others when writing your thread titles and try to err on the side of caution. Threads with spoilers or borderline spoilers in the title will be edited, or in some cases removed.
Finally: any user maliciously spoiling games for others may find themselves unable to participate in any Giant Bomb community features for a lengthy period of time, if not forever. So please, don't be that guy. It isn't funny and no one wants people like that around, so please just don't put the mods in a position of having to ban you because you thought it would be cute to try and spoil a game for a bunch of people.
Phew, that's a lot. Thanks for bearing with me, I just want to make sure that as few people as possible end up getting The Phantom Pain spoiled for them. This is just a first draft and I'll probably do some editing and maybe another draft before putting up a copy of this as it's own post in the Phantom Pain forum sometime over the next couple of days or so. To everyone who got this far...thanks for reading this long ass post!
Log in to comment