bshirk's Metroid: Other M (Wii) review

Avatar image for bshirk

Samus shedding her bathing suit wouldn't save this game


Last September, I was bombarded with tweets about Metroid: Other M being sexist. Each time I saw one of those 140-character messages, I rolled my eyes thinking that Americans were once again expecting an indestructible, emotionless space marine. Admittedly, a tear-shedding Samus would have been a bit different from the stoic heroine of prior space-faring adventures, but I wouldn’t exactly pound my fists and spill my coffee.  A bulletproof woman or man is not essential to my enjoyment of a sci-fi adventure, but I do expect a competent game that makes at least as much sense as Star Wars.   Sadly, Team Ninja pulled a Cain & Abel and murdered the Metroid saga by including Adam and forging a new Samus out of his rib.

Samus’ last outing took the form of a first-person adventure game where the player would scour massive worlds for precious power-ups, fight zippy space pirates, and listen to ethereal music. Other M doesn’t do away with unlockables or space pirates, but it does put the player in a different perspective.

In Other M, the player controls Samus from a third-person viewpoint, so it’s a throwback of sorts to Super Metroid and Metroid Fusion, which makes sense since the adventure occurs between those two titles. Unfortunately, Other M doesn’t even have the sense of exploration of Samus’ side-scrolling adventures, as you’re frequently forced down narrow corridors with hidden power-ups already revealed on your map, and you can rarely venture from your linear route.

This wouldn’t be much of an issue if the environments were aesthetically pleasing and the controls were precise. Sadly, both are as ugly as the aliens Samus encounters. The generic, metallic hallways look like they were created with RPG Maker and Samus controls like a runaway 18-wheeler.  You’ll occasionally encounter an open environment, but the lifeless jungles and poor combat will make you wonder if you’re playing a flash game.

Samus eventually obtains the same skill-set she has in every other Metroid title, but none of these moves are fun to use, since they’re imprecise. Shooting at enemies feels like spraying ants with a squirt gun, as your beam arm somehow manages to miss enemies at times even though it’s set to auto-aim.  Her other moves such as shooting missiles are equally frustrating, as you have to switch the position of your controller and rely on the incredibly slow cursor.

Even ignoring Other M’s disastrous controls, it still doesn’t impress. The cut-scenes look decent, but the story and voice acting feel like a third grader’s first creative work. Samus’ generic soldier buddies will make you consider abandoning the service, but her obedience to her former officer named Adam feels like a war crime. Even though she can probably kick her entire squad’s ass with her arsenal blindfolded, she decides not to use power bombs and missiles because Adam says so. Clearly this abominable game is not Eve’s fault: It’s Adam’s.

Other reviews for Metroid: Other M (Wii)

    Metroid: Other M is a disappointment by any measure 0

    I was an excited 6 year old when Metroid II: The Return of Samus was released for the Game Boy. I've been a huge fan of the series ever since. It's been literally years since I've bought a Wii game, but I knew I wasn't going to pass up the next game in the Metroid series, even if some of what I was seeing in trailers seemed a bit out of place. Things like free missile and health recharges definitely seemed strange, but if they worked within the context of the gameplay, then who really cares?Afte...

    20 out of 23 found this review helpful.

    It certainly is "Other". 0

    Let me just start off by saying I love Metroid. Metroid, Super Metroid, the three Prime games, the GBA games, are all super in my book. Other M, however, is really not one of those games at all and while that maybe means it lives up to its sub title.  Controls are just plain weird and that doesn’t bode well for an action game. Some really unusual choices were made with this game as it uses the Wiimote minus nunchuk and motion plus, that’s right only the wiimote is used for the controls. That giv...

    6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.