The Good

• Great sense of motion and fluidity. The game is fantastic when you successfully hit jump after jump. Some of the moves you can pull off are bad ass, and once you hit a groove you'll feel unstoppable.
• Great visuals. The simple colors work really well, and look great against the white. A lot of the rooms and situations look the same, but they all have different ways of being handled and manuvered.
• Unique. Definitely feels different than anything I've ever played before, which is saying a lot. The lack of combat is definitely a welcome change, especially since Edge's Combat isn't exactly fantastic.
• Simple. Three buttons, and most of the puzzles are pretty straightforward. Doesn't take very long to get used to using the bumpers and triggers, and it feels very natural once you do.

The Bad

• Random difficulty spikes. Most of the game's puzzles are straightforward enough to get after the first or second time, but some, especially when there are enemies involved, can be annoying.
• You die a lot. I've played my share of video games, and I'd like to say I'm pretty good at them, but I've died a lot in this game so far. You don't jump far enough, your wall-run doesn't carry you far enough, you get hit by a fucking train, etc. You'll be dying a lot in this game, no matter how good you are.
• Too bright. Some of the outside levels had me running up giant white walls that were so bright you couldn't distinguish what was what. Turning the brightness and contrast down only takes away from the look of the game, and while it does fix a few things, only leaves the environment looking muddy and evening-ish.
• Cutscenes. I feel like I should be buying auto insurance. Story is so-so, but I didn't expect too much going in.
• Short. Only a few hours long, and it lacks a multiplayer mode. Not to mention Race mode only has you going through the same levels. Hopefully some challenge rooms will be released as DLC later on. Still wouldn't justify this being a $60 game. $40 seems about right.
• Rarely hits it's stride. Mirror's Edge is great when you get a good rhythm going, but problem is, not only do you rarely get into this rhythm, but it never lasts very long once you do. The prologue level is definitely a thrill, since most of the puzzles can be figured out fairly quickly, but standing around trying to figure out puzzles is hardly what this game should be about.

The Good

• Great sense of motion and fluidity. The game is fantastic when you successfully hit jump after jump. Some of the moves you can pull off are bad ass, and once you hit a groove you'll feel unstoppable.
• Great visuals. The simple colors work really well, and look great against the white. A lot of the rooms and situations look the same, but they all have different ways of being handled and manuvered.
• Unique. Definitely feels different than anything I've ever played before, which is saying a lot. The lack of combat is definitely a welcome change, especially since Edge's Combat isn't exactly fantastic.
• Simple. Three buttons, and most of the puzzles are pretty straightforward. Doesn't take very long to get used to using the bumpers and triggers, and it feels very natural once you do.

The Bad

• Random difficulty spikes. Most of the game's puzzles are straightforward enough to get after the first or second time, but some, especially when there are enemies involved, can be annoying.
• You die a lot. I've played my share of video games, and I'd like to say I'm pretty good at them, but I've died a lot in this game so far. You don't jump far enough, your wall-run doesn't carry you far enough, you get hit by a fucking train, etc. You'll be dying a lot in this game, no matter how good you are.
• Too bright. Some of the outside levels had me running up giant white walls that were so bright you couldn't distinguish what was what. Turning the brightness and contrast down only takes away from the look of the game, and while it does fix a few things, only leaves the environment looking muddy and evening-ish.
• Cutscenes. I feel like I should be buying auto insurance. Story is so-so, but I didn't expect too much going in.
• Short. Only a few hours long, and it lacks a multiplayer mode. Not to mention Race mode only has you going through the same levels. Hopefully some challenge rooms will be released as DLC later on. Still wouldn't justify this being a $60 game. $40 seems about right.
• Rarely hits it's stride. Mirror's Edge is great when you get a good rhythm going, but problem is, not only do you rarely get into this rhythm, but it never lasts very long once you do. The prologue level is definitely a thrill, since most of the puzzles can be figured out fairly quickly, but standing around trying to figure out puzzles is hardly what this game should be about.

I kinda agree with you ! and I'll certainly  look forward to Mirror's Edge 2 .

I think I'll be able to get over the flaws you listed. I'm definitely going to pick this game up sometime this year. Just have to get my money's worth out of LittleBigPlanet, Resistance 2, and Fallout 3 first... Which will take a while. =P

well every game has room for improvement. also any problems can be over looked if there are alot of good things.

Wow, I agree with you 100%. 

I would add to "Too bright", "Too dark."  While the outdoor levels are sometimes blinding, some of the indoor ones are so dark it's very difficult to figure out what to do.

But still, it's definitely worth playing.  I want a Tomb Raider game done like this.