Let's be real, Burnout Paradise came out in 2008 and it is still the undisputed greatest open-world racing game of all time. Need for Speed 2015 doesn't change that. It doesn't even come close. Criterion, the developers who made Burnout Paradise were bought up by EA some years back and made Need For Speed: Most Wanted in 2012 which came closer to recapturing that old magic than this new game does. But Criterion doesn't really exist anymore and now chasing the ghost of Burnout Paradise is EA's new studio Ghost. The result is a game that tries to strike a balance between that bombastic, over-the-top spectacle of Burnout Paradise and the gritty, tuner-centric realism of EA's Shift games. The game is simultaneously brilliant and stupid and frustrating and gorgeous.

Right off the line I found that the sound is the best part of Need For Speed. I'm a big drum and bass fan, and the soundtrack is rife with some fantastic D&B tunes. The score for the game was done by none other than Photek and the licensed soundtrack has a very eclectic, modern and deep mix. I mean, they got that Rio song by Netsky 6 months before it was even released!

The people who worked on the audio should be extremely proud. Every sound effect, engine note, collision and tire squeal has a pop and weight to it that sounds illustrious in a good pair of headphones. And I can't heap enough praise on the subtle touch of having the music volume raise and lower dynamically with the speed of the car. It's utterly brilliant; perfectly capturing the rush of pegging the accelerator while cranking the volume knob. Inspired.

Visually, Need for Speed is downright resplendent. That's if you like the color palette of blue and pink. The production designers did an amazing job of creating an entire city with distinctly different districts and areas that all look unique and yet mesh perfectly into a cohesive color and design palate. The game operates on a unique dusk/dawn cycle rather than a full day/night cycle. Which means like it or not, you'll be driving at night for the entire game. At the end of the night you'll crest a hill and see dazzling sunbeams dancing through the tree branches as the sun rises. Moments later the sun will sink back below the horizon and plunge you back into eternal evening. The darkness may get a bit monotonous, but there's no denying that the wet pavement reflecting back your tail lights as you drift around corners in the middle of a dark and rainy night is atmospheric as hell. The car models are impeccable and between body kits and decals, the amount of customization you can perform on them is outright daunting.

You just can't talk about the visuals in Need for Speed without mentioning the cutscenes. Attempting to weave a narrative between all of the races and cop chases Need for Speed employs live action cutscenes shot from the first-person perspective. The cutscenes look fantastic. The lighting, set design and the actors all look spot-on as if they belong in the world you've been racing in and extra touches of seeing your customized car composited into the middle of a scene fuse the two elements well. It's admirable from a technical perspective. That being said, the cutscenes are terrible, and not in a good way. The actors did their best with the material and direction they were given but it all boils down to the writing and the fact that there are just too many characters. The narrative just kind of fizzles and doesn't really go anywhere despite having some early potential. The gameplay presents a compelling reason to have five main characters in that each character represents a particular style/aspect of racing, but it's too much to actually build any kind of meaningful character development. Ultimately the biggest problem with the cutscenes is that they ride the line. On the one hand, they could have leaned hard on the realism spectrum, get some racing consultants and portray street racing as accurately as possible. Early on, the game does a good job building tension around the group's suspicion of who could be the outlaw in town baiting cops into chases, causing trouble for all of the other street racers. More of that and less fist bumping, energy drink tossing, bromides could have been something special. On the flip side, they could have gone back to the Razor Callahan camp-fest from Need For Speed: Most Wanted (2005) and just get wacky and ridiculous with it. Need for Speed 2015 feels like they couldn't decide how to tackle it so they just toed the line which isn't what anybody wanted.

I would have also liked to have seen a bit more interactivity with the characters. Not only are there cutscenes but lots of phone calls and voice messages while you're driving around. Typically after every race the organizer calls you to commiserate or congratulate. But it would have been a cool touch to include some sound bites for specific scenarios like banging up your ride beyond recognition or getting set upon by the cops and escaping by the skin of your teeth. Just a quick throwaway line to acknowledge the crazy shit that just went down would have gone a long way.

The amount of style oozing out of Need for Speed isn't necessarily all that surprising. All of the EA racing games from the last few years, whether they be from the Need for Speed series or the Shift series have had amazing sound design, art direction and production design. Need for Speed 2015 doesn't deviate and unfortunately, when it comes to gameplay it also doesn't drift too far from the others. Much like its predecessors, driving cars in Need for Speed just feels…off. It's tough to qualify exactly what is going on under the hood here. In the game's garage you have the opportunity to tinker with everything on your car. Swap out tires, change the amount of downforce coming off your aerokit, adjust your suspension, soften your sway bars, but no amount of tuning ever left me feeling completely satisfied with the way my car performed. The game lets you vacillate between drift cars and grip cars and you can change your road-hugging, earth-shoveling grip monster into a loosey-goosey, side-winding high plains drifter whenever you want. The developers even included a handy slider you can use to change from grip to drift (or any point in between) if adjusting all of the minutia is too overwhelming. After all that, however, none of it ever seemed to gain traction. I tried buying better cars and tuning the shit out of the ones in my stable but in the end, every time I'd go out for a ride that dope-ass feeling of driving like unassailable hoonigan was deflated by one or more of the following:

1. Collision detection: you bump a guard rail nine times and bounce back onto the road but on the tenth your car does triple Salchow into oblivion.
2. You coming cruising off that nice straight expressway and into some serious drift territory, you tap the brake and try to kick out the back tires, but either understeer or oversteer yourself right into the guard rail (oh and drift competitions don't add the points your rack up in a drift to your total score if you collide with something).
3. Some asshole hits you. The world is populated with online players and NPC (non-player character) drivers that race around and do events. You'll be minding your own business, doing your thing and a pack of idiots will come around the bend going the wrong way in a one way and wreck your run.
4. You can plow through street lights, mailboxes, dumpsters and electrical transformer boxes like they're made of paper mache, but a small sapling of a maple tree? Fucking impervious.
5. Cops. The cops aren't all bad. The sound design is fantastic for the cop chases. As soon as you get spotted Photek's Heat-inspired score rises up and you feel the tension as you try to outmaneuver and outrace your way to freedom. Annoyances pop up when the cops manage to bust you as you're hung up on something (like a goddamn maple tree) or find yourself going in circles trying to find that ever elusive onramp to the expressway. Ultimately getting chased by the cops wasn't that big of a deal, but touches like not being able to restart an event/race because you're being pursued were lame.

I wanted to love Need for Speed. I wouldn't go so far as to say it’s a bad game. It has so many shining positives but ultimately it has too many gameplay issues holding it back for it to be great. I could feel my enthusiasm slipping like tires on wet pavement, but I hope Ghost gets the opportunity to rev up a sequel. With tweaks and a bit more polish Need for Speed 2 or whatever the hell they would call it could be seriously dope.

I started off thinking the game was okay. Then I got into it for a hot minute. Then ended up hating it by about 70% completion. This game has so many issues. It really makes me miss 2012 Most Wanted. That was the last good NFS game.

I totally agree. I forgave a lot of the problems I was having in the beginning because I thought I just needed to get a better car. By the time I got myself a 1000+ horsepower ride I realized it solved none of my problems and I stopped playing. Need For Speed: Most Wanted was so excellent. I hope Ghost takes a hard look at that game and their game and try to find some middle ground for the sequel (if there is a sequel).

I finally managed to pick this up for PC about two months ago and was kicking around the idea of doing my own write-up on it while playing it, so it's great to see other people on this site voice an opinion on it.

I don't take as big an issue with some of the lackluster or outright "flawed" aspects of the game. As for as control goes, I managed to get the cars to turn and drift as they did in Criterion's Hot Pursuit pretty easily by buying drift ties and turning off one of the stabilization settings. Yeah, it is annoying when either another drivers hits you head on or you take a bad turn into a tree, but it's not too far off from the obstacles and challenges that other racing games have. And as much as I really enjoyed Burnout Paradise on 360, I also differ from the general consensus of Paradise being the best racing game and that every racing game should aspire to be it, though mainly for the sake of letting other racing games do other things instead of being in Paradise's shadow. This Need for Speed much closer to the Underground 1 through Carbon era of NFS since it encapsulates and updates the nightlife world aesthetic and dude bro character types from those games, as opposed to trying to be another Paradise, like Most Wanted 2012 was trying to do, and have every character being Razor Callahan, as much of a cult favorite he ended up being.

But I ultimately agree overall in that this is just an okay game; nothing that would get people to fall in love with the NFS games again. I did go in with lowered expectations because of the Quick Look, Jeff's review, not seeing much enthusiasm about it on this site, and also the NFS franchise overall just feeling like it's been floundering around for the past several years, while other racing games like Forza (both the Motorsport and Horizon series'), GRID, Dirt, Blur, Driver: San Francisco, iRacing and Project CARS seem like the more popular and more enjoyable choices for racing games these days. I can confidentially say that this is one of the better NFS games to come out in a while; certainly better than ProStreet, Undercover, and The Run so I can't say that I'm disappointed in buying it (though not at full price), but it could have done a bit more to keep me excited like Hot Pursuit 2010 did.

I honestly think Need for Speed Rivals is a better game than Paradise. Quite frankly I was never a huge fan of Paradise to begin with and the love for that game is baffling to me. It was fine, alright, but nothing about it really caught my attention. Maybe it's because I played it much later, who knows, I just never saw what everyone else saw. Had a heck of a fun time in Rivals though.

All this mentioning of the 2012 Most Wanted reallly makes me miss the 05 Most Wanted. Loved that game.

I from Belgium and they kept playing that Rio song from Netsky over and over again that i know really really hate it ! Also Great article really enjoyed it.

I'm with you on most of your points. This Need For Speed does a lot right on different fields, specially after the updates, but then the gameplay comes and ruins it's opportunity to be great.