boss_kowbel's Payday 2 (PC) review

Avatar image for boss_kowbel

Payday 2 Review: Making Bank

Murphy's Law eloquently teaches, "Anything that can go wrong, will go wrong." And with the don of a mask, the flick of a safety, the sound of a shot, no game demonstrates that sad truth better than Payday: The Heist’s sequel. Too often a pedestrian compromised my team’s jewelry store stickup by phoning in the disturbance, or an unnoticed security camera captured our bank break-in for the entire evening news. An unconscious bodyguard’s pager also ended several home invasions early, just like mixing the wrong meth ingredients led to an incapacitating explosion. Payday 2 is a periodic comedy of errors, but in a game so reliant on execution, it pays to have a backup plan. Literally.

Returning Payday protagonists Chains, Dallas, Wolf, and Hoxton find themselves at the center of Murphy’s old adage once again, but not even the most gullible viewers would believe their seasoned expertise when watching Payday 2’s computer-controlled AI. Twice I tackled heists alone, and only twice, because the missions demanded I handcuff civilians, carry suitcases, and repair drills while babysitting two idiotic partners-in-crime. They never cooperate, ignoring bags, intel, and hostages when they rush blindly into the open to resuscitate each other. Otherwise, the computer hounds your every step, just like a trusted canine, though it's far from man's best friend.

With Payday 2, we are several steps closer to a perfect reenactment of Heat.
With Payday 2, we are several steps closer to a perfect reenactment of Heat.

At least the game costs $30, because given its defunct AI, fans only get half a product. To make any progress, four semi-intelligent players is mandatory, but nothing else scratches the cooperative heist itch like Payday 2. First-person shooters pride themselves on showing off the next big set piece, or chaperoning gamers through endless firefights with little time to reflect on their actions. Instead, Overkill Software not only encourage patience, they actually reward it.

Before you can start planning your exotic retirement, you must start small. Felonies begin with, a citywide list of contracts for all burgeoning burglars. Immediately, Payday veterans will notice the staggering increase in dirty work. Malls need vandalizing, cocaine needs escorting, guns need stealing, and bureaucrats need blackmailing. Of course, what would the game be without a traditional bank robbery, too? The variety is the icing on the five-finger discount cake, and what filling, addictive icing it is, even after 15 hours.

Players start most thefts undercover, locating buildings' video cameras, memorizing guards' positions, taking a head count of civilians, and identifying entrances and exits. But random level layouts ensure no planning stage ends without hiccups. Now the back door's locked, the manager's missing, the brick walls are windows, and the bank vault's sitting in the lobby within plain view of the tellers and customers. Even so, improvising is the mark of any great thief, as is stealth. During my first silent heist, Dallas hacked the bank’s security feed, pinpointing patrolling police. Meanwhile, Wolf picked the lock to the accountant’s booth, ordering the employees to stand down before they tripped the alarm. Then, before anybody escaped, Hoxton blocked off the front door as I (Chains) set up the drill that would break into the vault. In and out in five minutes. The cops were never called, no innocents were harmed.

Players trade mobility for protection with bulletproof vests.
Players trade mobility for protection with bulletproof vests.

Harming civilians deducts a cleaning fee, but keeping the crowd under control is needlessly complicated by a Payday: The Heist frustration: the goddamn drills. Occasionally, the drill tips break when boring into a safe and need replacing. That eternity lasts nearly 15 seconds, during which time players remain vulnerable and prisoners can escape. Why would the characters not buy better tools using their ill-gotten currency? Because that would sour the ‘game’ part of the experience? No, it ruins the fun. At least Overkill Software added quicker, albeit more deafening, safe-cracking means. Power saws slice through locks, and C4 blows doors off their hinges, letting criminals amass more loot quickly.

Certain tools remain specific to the four classes. The Enforcer is a tank, able to carry bags faster, throw them farther, and dismantle locks with the saw. The Mastermind is manipulative, convincing cops to handcuff themselves or even fight for you when not acting as the team medic. The Technician is a master of explosives and the only one that can equip C4 – indispensable when getaway drivers leave stragglers behind. Lastly, Ghosts are the stealth artists, capable of deploying jammers that disable all nearby electronics.

The skill trees prove paramount to a group’s success, though Payday 2 allows players to be as dangerous as they want, like recruiting multiple Enforcers for jobs best done quietly. Testing what strategies works among your posse is a rare cerebral joy, bolstered by a community willing to help newcomers learn. Contracts vary in length and difficulty, so communication is a must at all stages. Simple smash and grabs divide the cash at the end of missions, while multi-day operations only roll out the big bucks once the ordeal's over. Rats, for example, is a three-day affair, requiring players to bake batches of meth and trade it for information on the traitors who sold them out.

Players could stay and pick every lockbox, or escape before more boys in blue arrive.
Players could stay and pick every lockbox, or escape before more boys in blue arrive.

Payday 2 is a frequent source of virtual greed I did not expect. Cause enough chaos before a getaway and the cops may randomly attack the vehicle between days, forcing teams into a brief standoff before a new driver arrives. Not surprisingly, stolen goods can be lost during these short shootouts, further reducing payouts. Do you endanger your group’s safety for an extra ten grand, or watch helplessly while officers carry bags away? Almost nine times out of ten, my crew chose the former.

I did not expect such a terrible upgrade system, either. After every job, players choose one of three cards containing bonus cash, weapon mods, or mask materials. Payday 2 then hands out unlocks for guns you don't even own, meaning you may, theoretically, never obtain a specific scope, barrel, grip, etc.

The in-game economy is similarly stingy. The game puts away millions of dollars in an untouchable offshore savings account, yet the player's pocket cash is just tens of thousands? The most costly firearms set buyers back half a million, which cuts into funds used to purchase class perks. Even custom masks demand a cool $100,000. For what? Chrome paint?

So with all the faults levied against you, Payday 2, why can I not quit you? Because Payday 2 is an exercise in both inner and outer conflict, and few experiences compare with casing a bank, syncing the siege with three other bandits, and making off with stacks of freshly minted bills. Sure, vaults swinging open to reveal another locked gate is gut-wrenching, especially when sounds of dubstep signal fresh waves of law enforcement. But disregarding its amateur AI, discount drills, and bogus award system, Payday 2's only punishable offense is stealing players' time.

Originally written for

Other reviews for Payday 2 (PC)

    Robbing banks, jewelry stores and dealers of contraband is great while the men in blue are away 0

    A good variety of heists that can be tackled in different ways, along with a slick presentation make the idea of more heist games exciting. As it stands though, PAYDAY 2 is mostly just a really well constructed cooperative first person shooter. That you can love it when a plan comes together is more of a bonus.Even though it can be played alone, it isn’t meant to be. The friendly A.I. is quick to revive you and can be quite the bullet sponge, but it can’t interact the way another player can. For...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Great game 0

    I've been playing this game for a while.Soundtrack 10/10 - Makes you feel like you're in a heist movie during the whole mission, precise transitions between themes. Makes you feel the tension, action & thrill at every moment.Overall Graphics Design 10/10 - Models & textures quality is exquisite.Ergonomic Gameplay Design 10/10 - You can learn it really fast.During the time I've been playing I've founf only one bug so far: I hit a frame on the wall while I ducked under it and I got stuck x...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.