I thought that the game was fun.  But the dog wasn't as revolutionary as the economic system, where you could buy and rent anything.  

I thought it was very good but, I did have some problems with it.  Overall if you have a 360 and are a fan of RPGs, then get this game.

Your poll seems to be confusing "lives up to Molyneux's promises" with "is good."  And they're not mutually exclusive - Fable didn't live up to Molyneux's promise at all, but it was still a good game.

In reality nothing that he said would be in the game wasn't there, so technically it did live up to the promises.
Personally though, not really.  While certain parts where freaking awesome, others were lame.  If they could ditch dungeons in the main mission and really them in general and make more momemnts like the...jees what's that place called?  Ahh... you probably know what I mean.

I liked interacting with the villagers.  Until you became too famous, then it was a pain.

I hate the question. Just enjoy the games instead of analyzing if they lived up to some developer talk or not. But still :
A: Totally, The game met all my expectations.

Nothing can live up to Molyneux's promises, ever.