GOTY 2016
This year is just a top 5 as I missed many of the big releases that I know would have composed by 6-10 spots. I feel very confident my top 3 would not change.
(Missing games I know may get added in updates later in the year - Dark Souls 3, Uncharted 4, Tyranny, The Witness, Firewatch)
*EDIT* After Finally getting to Uncharted 4, it pushed Abzu out to take the number 3 spot!