The bestest, most accurate GOTY of 2016
I don't feel particularily strongly about anything released this year, which is probably why the number 1 and 2 games on this list are the ones that are freshest on my mind. I also haven't played Doom, Hitman, Steep or Watch Dogs 2 yet and haven't put too many hours into Dishonored 2.
Retroactive honorable mention to Rainbow Six Siege for being the second best game of last year and the best multiplayer shooter this year.
Here's the list.