I love petty video game arguments
Me too! It's all of course very silly, but my personal favorite part of GOTY is the actual Top 10 where they debate placement and inclusion of all their favorite games.
I like this part every year: They spend a ton of time trying to narrow it down to like 12 games, and then someone, probably Jeff, says, "So the order the games are on this doc, is this just the list then?" and then someone, probably Ben, says "Swap X and Y, and I'm good with it", and someone else, probably Brad, comes in, "Over my dead body are you swapping those games!" and then the true fun commences.