Something went wrong. Try again later

DeadManRollin

This user has not updated recently.

79 305 24 10
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

2011: A Great Year for RPG Gamers (Witcher 2)

When the first reviews of Witcher came out, I wasn't really interested about the game. However, after reading the considerably better reviews for the enhanced edition, I really got interested in the game and bought it. The experience of playing witcher was totally a new one from me. I bought it just after playing Oblivion and completing Neverwinter Nights, and I was expecting a character creation screen at the very beginning of the game.

No Caption Provided


The below portion will have spoilers regarding Witcher, so please don't read if you haven't completed the game.

But no, there wasn't any. Witcher does not have any character creation and or customization options. You get a badass hero named Geralt to play with, who has recently lost his memory. The game quickly takes you to Geralt's first romantic interest. She reminds him that he was "really good in bed" before he lost his memory.  This was one of the many unique aspects of this game.

The combat was totally different from anything I've ever seen before. Before playing witcher, I had experience with Drakensang, Neverwinter Nights, Oblivion and Dungeon Siege 2. But none of those games had 3 different battle stances, and neither limited the types of weapons the protagonist could use or carry. While Geralt can only use a regular sword and a silver sword (axes and knives, too, if I remember correctly), the heroes in other games could wield daggers, staffs, shields, maces, bows and what not. As a unique twist, Geralt can also unleash a number of spells that can affect the gameplay dramatically.

I got really indulged in the game, and I must say, Witcher was the first RPG game that gave me the creeps. Walking through the fields at night was an unforgettable experience. I am yet to see another game properly utilize day and night effects to a useful manner. Dragon Age 2 makes some quests available only at night, but that's not even remotely comparable to the brilliance of Witcher.

The character is fully voiced, and dialogues have real impact in the way NPC react and quests unveil. The frustrating part is that in most cases, you will not get a second chance to provide the right response and get the quest done. So you really need to follow the story in order to get the desired outcome. Like there is one instance where you can either kill a witch, have sex with her and let her leave or have sex with her and let the mob kill her. It is a bit difficult to understand what will lead to what and I was totally flabbergasted when my unmindful responses led to the burning of her by the mob.

So I had to reload an older game and replay that portion.

I just wrote about Dragon Age 2 in my last entry, and it amazes me to realize how deep and involving witcher was. It's a 4 year old game, and still very much recommended and playable. And with Witcher 2 coming out within the next 3 weeks, this could be the best thing to do--replaying Witcher and getting ready for the sequel.

Unfortunately for me, I could never complete the game. There was this stage called marsh which broke the game for me. That level was tedious, and path finding was a chore. I played for hours (without resorting to walthroughs) in vain just to find out any quest element. The map was not helpful, and the journal is a bit difficult.

I still feel like going back to this great game and I think I will do it soon. Witcher is in my opinion a one of a kind RPG game. Dragon Age: Origins tried to bring some adult theme in to the game, but the ones depicted in Witcher are much more involving(!) and satisfying.

I started playing Dragon Age: Origins when I got stuck in Witcher. I guess that is one good reason as to why I never got back to Witcher. Playing the 50 plus hour campaign 6 times, and then going for DA2 over the last 2 years have made it impossible for me to go back to Witcher.

But now is the time for revisiting Geralt's old story--before the new one unveils. I also have a new GPU now so things should look nicer, too. I used to have a Geforce 8600 GT back then, and now I own an AMD 6870.
14 Comments

14 Comments

Avatar image for deadmanrollin
DeadManRollin

79

Forum Posts

305

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By DeadManRollin

When the first reviews of Witcher came out, I wasn't really interested about the game. However, after reading the considerably better reviews for the enhanced edition, I really got interested in the game and bought it. The experience of playing witcher was totally a new one from me. I bought it just after playing Oblivion and completing Neverwinter Nights, and I was expecting a character creation screen at the very beginning of the game.

No Caption Provided


The below portion will have spoilers regarding Witcher, so please don't read if you haven't completed the game.

But no, there wasn't any. Witcher does not have any character creation and or customization options. You get a badass hero named Geralt to play with, who has recently lost his memory. The game quickly takes you to Geralt's first romantic interest. She reminds him that he was "really good in bed" before he lost his memory.  This was one of the many unique aspects of this game.

The combat was totally different from anything I've ever seen before. Before playing witcher, I had experience with Drakensang, Neverwinter Nights, Oblivion and Dungeon Siege 2. But none of those games had 3 different battle stances, and neither limited the types of weapons the protagonist could use or carry. While Geralt can only use a regular sword and a silver sword (axes and knives, too, if I remember correctly), the heroes in other games could wield daggers, staffs, shields, maces, bows and what not. As a unique twist, Geralt can also unleash a number of spells that can affect the gameplay dramatically.

I got really indulged in the game, and I must say, Witcher was the first RPG game that gave me the creeps. Walking through the fields at night was an unforgettable experience. I am yet to see another game properly utilize day and night effects to a useful manner. Dragon Age 2 makes some quests available only at night, but that's not even remotely comparable to the brilliance of Witcher.

The character is fully voiced, and dialogues have real impact in the way NPC react and quests unveil. The frustrating part is that in most cases, you will not get a second chance to provide the right response and get the quest done. So you really need to follow the story in order to get the desired outcome. Like there is one instance where you can either kill a witch, have sex with her and let her leave or have sex with her and let the mob kill her. It is a bit difficult to understand what will lead to what and I was totally flabbergasted when my unmindful responses led to the burning of her by the mob.

So I had to reload an older game and replay that portion.

I just wrote about Dragon Age 2 in my last entry, and it amazes me to realize how deep and involving witcher was. It's a 4 year old game, and still very much recommended and playable. And with Witcher 2 coming out within the next 3 weeks, this could be the best thing to do--replaying Witcher and getting ready for the sequel.

Unfortunately for me, I could never complete the game. There was this stage called marsh which broke the game for me. That level was tedious, and path finding was a chore. I played for hours (without resorting to walthroughs) in vain just to find out any quest element. The map was not helpful, and the journal is a bit difficult.

I still feel like going back to this great game and I think I will do it soon. Witcher is in my opinion a one of a kind RPG game. Dragon Age: Origins tried to bring some adult theme in to the game, but the ones depicted in Witcher are much more involving(!) and satisfying.

I started playing Dragon Age: Origins when I got stuck in Witcher. I guess that is one good reason as to why I never got back to Witcher. Playing the 50 plus hour campaign 6 times, and then going for DA2 over the last 2 years have made it impossible for me to go back to Witcher.

But now is the time for revisiting Geralt's old story--before the new one unveils. I also have a new GPU now so things should look nicer, too. I used to have a Geforce 8600 GT back then, and now I own an AMD 6870.
Avatar image for slasherman
SlasherMan

1723

Forum Posts

53

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By SlasherMan
@DeadManRollin said:
"Unfortunately for me, I could never complete the game. There was this stage called marsh which broke the game for me. That level was tedious, and path finding was a chore. I played for hours (without resorting to walthroughs) in vain just to find out any quest element. "
I don't recall having such an issue when I played it. If you get stuck, you could always consult an online guide.
You should really attempt to replay the game, because you have not even come close to the good parts if you stopped at the marsh (I'm assuming Chapter 2 or 3, right?).

But yes, definitely agree with everything you said. I enjoyed The Witcher a lot more than I did Dragon Age (which actually turned out to be far too grindy for my taste, and dragged on quite a bit).
I have really high hopes for the sequel.
Avatar image for deadmanrollin
DeadManRollin

79

Forum Posts

305

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By DeadManRollin
@SlasherMan: Yes bro, I think I stopped in the third chapter. For some reason, I never managed to seek help from an online guide when I got stuck. That is why I want to get back to it. I really do.
Avatar image for contro
Contro

2346

Forum Posts

-1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Contro

@DeadManRollin:

 


Agreed, It is a true adult orientated RPG, despite the quirky sexual stuff which doesn't feel very adult at all. 
Yea, you really should before playing the sequel, I would also highly recommend that you read The Last Wish. My PC engineer is Polish, I recently introduced him to the game and now he can't wait to play the sequel also. 
I've signed up on Amazon for the awesome looking collectors edition. 


No Caption Provided

I've got a rare copy of the original:

No Caption Provided



Avatar image for deadmanrollin
DeadManRollin

79

Forum Posts

305

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By DeadManRollin
@Contro:  WoW man, the collector's edition really looks awesome. Thanks for the link
Avatar image for contro
Contro

2346

Forum Posts

-1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Contro

I know, it's easily one of the best I've seen for a PC game in all my years. It's going to cost a fair bit, but for fans it'll be worth the expense. I really want that Geralt bust ^^

PS: You've posted this in Off Topic rather than The Witcher 2 forum - you can ask a mod to have it moved.    

Avatar image for melcene
melcene

3214

Forum Posts

1475

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 9

Edited By melcene

Deja vu.... didn't someone else just (within the last week or so) post a blog about 2011 being the year of the RPG based off like one game?  


Anyway... I didn't think DA2 was so spectacular as to make this a great year for RPGs, and I couldn't really get into the first Witcher a whole lot.  Then again, I had the original buggy version.

That being said, we do still have things like Elder Scrolls V, Mass Effect 3, Dungeon Seige III, and possibly Diablo III, so we'll see how the rest of the year goes.
Avatar image for crusader8463
crusader8463

14850

Forum Posts

4290

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 5

Edited By crusader8463

I will never understand the love people give for this game. I have tried about a dozen times now to get into the game, but I just can't do it. I hate the combat, the controls, the characters all look terribly designed, I hated the VO, the story never did anything for me, and the world just felt generic and bland. I only made it to the first village with the werewolf things attacking people, so maybe it gets better after that, but the time I spent with that game up to that point never gave me any reason to keep trying past that point.


All of that said however, I'm thinking about giving it another chance since the next one is coming out, but I don't think it will do anything this time. Who knows though. Maybe this time I will just force myself to keep playing it and see how it all ends up.

Glad others are enjoying it so much.
Avatar image for contro
Contro

2346

Forum Posts

-1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Contro
@melcene: 

If you still have it, you should download the free EE update. It improves many aspects that were initially criticised.
Avatar image for animasta
Animasta

14950

Forum Posts

3563

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 5

Edited By Animasta
@Contro said:
" @melcene: 

If you still have it, you should download the free EE update. It improves many aspects that were initially criticised.
"
and the world is totally not generic; what's an ungeneric world for you exactly?
Avatar image for melcene
melcene

3214

Forum Posts

1475

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 9

Edited By melcene
@Laketown: Think you replied to the wrong person.  I didn't call the world generic.

@Contro: Hmm I'll check into that because I think I do still have the game around somewhere.  I didn't realize that there was a free EE update.  I thought you had to bite the bullet and buy the EE.
Avatar image for contro
Contro

2346

Forum Posts

-1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Contro
@Laketown said:

" @Contro said:

" @melcene: 

If you still have it, you should download the free EE update. It improves many aspects that were initially criticised.
"

and the world is totally not generic; what's an ungeneric world for you exactly? "

Your replying to the wrong person, who you should be replying to is:  crusader8463
Avatar image for deadmanrollin
DeadManRollin

79

Forum Posts

305

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By DeadManRollin

I found the combat ingenious...totally out of trend. However, it took me a while to get used to it. There was this underground cave that I entered where I couldn't see anything without wielding a flare. But some creep came out whom could not be damaged by flames. So i had to use the silver sword and whip at them in almost total darkness. That was a unique situation, which can cause annoyance. But then again, you can also give credit to the developers to give you food for thought. I dragged the battle outside of the room and found a area where sunlight was coming through a cracked wall. This kind of strategic battles are rare now. DA2 says it all.

Although I didn't finish the game, the amount I played remains memorable to me only for the unique situations I had to go through.

Avatar image for nemt
nemt

949

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By nemt

That's a funny way to spell Persona 5.