I mean as if there are not enough posts about this anyways. 
 
So do you really want to know? 
 
Do you even care? 
 
you do? 
 
Thats good! 
 
Scroll down! 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Street Fighter IV baby!

Wrong answer.

Close, but the correct answer is actually Barbie and the Three Musketeers for PC, DS, and Wii.

Eh, (Blog Post) is so overrated. The writing sucks, there's graphical overload EVERYWHERE, and I feel like this game SHOULD HAVE been delayed 'til 2010.

" Wrong answer. "

Uncharted 2 without a doubt

I often find it hard to give major awards to fighting games (much like its hard for the academy to give serious awards to action movies). 
Thats not to say it isn't deserving, because it is certainly one of the best fighters in years, but I still think there are better games out there

" @DanielJW: lol  What would yours be good sir. "

" Eh, (Blog Post) is so overrated. The writing sucks, there's graphical overload EVERYWHERE, and I feel like this game SHOULD HAVE been delayed 'til 2010. "

" @AgentJ: Your probably thinking MW2, but yeah, just my favorite game of the year. "

" @Webby: For you maybe, for me, no.  Thought that game was kinda dry, more onto Jeff's take on it. "

Man...this is why game of the year crap is all about fanboyism and epic failing.
 
the VGA announce their picks and people are already flinging mud around like it's nobodies business, myself included. Now everyone has an opinion on the game of the year already, and all of them are wrong, or right, in some way.  A lot of good games, a lot of decent games that are hyped to be good, like Modern Warfare 2 or Street Fighter IV, and a bunch of games that got little press but are pretty kick ass, like Demon Souls and Scribblenauts. 

" @demontium:

   "

The correct answer is either Borderlands or Red Faction Guerrilla.

The year is filled with great games, but these lists are still arbitrary and pointless because of the diverse palette of video games as it is. Nothing wrong with Street Fighter IV, it's a good game that I play. But it is not game of the year. Same goes for what I mentioned, although I might like them I would not consider either as game of the year. Point being though is that it can be anything, and that is why stuff like this fails.

" Wrong answer. "

1. Uncharted 2
2. Shatter
3. ?
   

1. Borderlands 
2. inFamous  
 
...that's all i got

I absolutely agree with you OP. In years time MW2, Uncharted 2 and likely Batman will all lose quality. Street Fighter will not.

"

1. Uncharted 2
2. Shatter
3. ?
   

"

My Xfire Activity report does not lie about my favorite games this year!

That's alot of hours for a week though -.- Does it show it wasn't a very busy week for me at all? :p

" Wrong answer. "

inFAMOUS is without a doubt mine. Shatter, Fat Princess and Bionic Commando are up there for sure.

good choice... (the sane persons choice) 
 
 maybe you should play G.I Joe rise of cobra or tony hawks ride before you come up with a definitive number one though.

" Wrong answer. "

Street Fighter IV?  Really?  Out of all of the games?  Well to each their own I suppose.  My vote goes to Uncharted 2.  Never before has a single-player experience kept me on the edge of my seat the way that Uncharted 2 has.  They really improved the story-telling elements of video games with that title.  Close runner-ups would be MW2, Demon's Souls, Torchlight and Dragon Age: Origins.  Also, this is not a complete list of games that I have played this year and think are worthy of notice.

" Eh, (Blog Post) is so overrated. The writing sucks, there's graphical overload EVERYWHERE, and I feel like this game SHOULD HAVE been delayed 'til 2010. "

As much as fun as I had with Street Fighter IV this year, it is not my number one choice for game of the year.

1 vs 100 is mine.

Why do people keep saying inFamous? Didn't that come out last year?
 
And, yes, the correct answer is Uncharted 2.

Actually, I believe your GOTY is NFS:SHIFT!.

It's obviously either Assassin's Creed II, Batman: Arkham Asylum, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, Left 4 Dead 2, or Uncharted 2: Among Thieves.

" @demontium said:

" @Webby: For you maybe, for me, no.  Thought that game was kinda dry, more onto Jeff's take on it. "

WTF?  Really, I almost had to pause the game at one point cause it got so freaking amazing I was just like "Whoa" "OMFG" "No way". lolThe train part and the car chase is crazy.  Just wondering how much of it have you played.  I understand people like different games but to me the game is really good on so many different levels. I guess it's just not for you. "

Does anyone get the sneaking suspicion that this year's GB Game of the Year bombcast is going to be a back and forth between MW2 and Uncharted 2 ? They seem to be the standout games this year, even though I think inFamous and Batman AA are being criminally overlooked by most people.

 this years been kinda boring but il go for dragon age last nice to have a fansaty rpg that rocks ather 3 years (Obivoen