DevourerOfTime

@banefirelord: I personally don't know if it would even crack my Top 10 of the decade personally, but I couldn't possibly deny that it is far and away the most popular choice for Game of the Decade among pretty much every type of list I found. While Dark Souls and Mass Effect 2 were buoyed by considerations elsewhere on lists, with Breath of the Wild if you just took the #1 votes for it, it would still be in 5th place, just barely behind Witcher 3.

@bumpton: Rock Band 3 was actually #101, barely being beaten out by Super Meat Boy by the slimmest of margins.

I think the reason behind it not making it is because people, generally, love Rock Band 2 more than 3, but 2 that was 2008. I personally always preferred 3 because I loved the rock band network stuff.

Nobody mentioned 4 though, which is unfortunate. I know a lot of people were disappointed by it, but it did what it needed to do: bring Rock Band to the current generation and let the good times keep rolling for those who want to plunk a few bucks on new songs one night with friends. I know people who still play it regularly to this day.

And nobody mentioned Blitz either. Well *I* thought it was neat at least...

@undeadpool said:

It certainly was in the top 100 from the other sources, but would not be nearly as high on the list without the giant bomb lists.

Persona 5 has a ton of problems. Like an absolute ton. And barely any of them are fixed in Royal (some are even made *worse* from what I've read of the japanese release). But I still loved it? I love so much about it? It's, like I said in the list, a very problematic game to have as your favourite, but I still enjoyed it more than most games on this list, even if the problems make me so angry.

Persona 5, though, was where I drew the line and never gave Atlus the benefit of the doubt again. I don't think I've bought a game by them since other than Etrian Odyssey V (which has a very inclusive character creator btw).

Rorie would be so proud.

I just feel so bad for you for putting yourself through that.

@humanity:

@manburger: Thanks! I put a lot of effort into it. Pretty happy with how it turned out.

Going to be doing a little more decade retrospective stuff in the future. Not of this magnitude, but still something people might find interesting!

I put way too much effort into this Game of the Decade list.

Blog: https://www.giantbomb.com/profile/devoureroftime/blog/the-peoples-game-of-the-decade/144736/

List: https://www.giantbomb.com/profile/devoureroftime/lists/the-peoples-game-of-the-decade/367782/

The list is finished.

Okay, while I haven't actually written it, I don't think I'll get that done tonight. So I just went ahead and added the rest of the list. I'll get back to that later this week.

https://www.giantbomb.com/profile/devoureroftime/lists/the-peoples-game-of-the-decade-unfinished/367782/

Mew got robbed.