This discussion has gone on since the site launched and will probably continue to do so until the site closes down one day.
The site's content is received positively to begin with, then people become disenchanted and annoyed or upset or just generally negative about it before eventually returning to a positively euphoric feeling towards the site again.
It's all down to a thing called change. Over time change causes different things to happen resulting in different reactions which provide lots of feedback which in turn steer the direction of future content to be delivered.
It's a very human thing to get annoyed about what we have available to us when we've had too much of a good thing. We go through phases of over indulgence and obsession (especially gamers) only to find that thing we loved so thoroughly has become the object of our scorn.
Guaranteed in a few months the people currently happy with the site's content will be annoyed by something and vice versa for those currently unhappy.
The only cure for this issue is to play video games and/or go out in the fresh air and find something else to do before coming back with a fresh approach.