@jakob187: The game came out just as they were recording these so they didn't have time to play enough of the game to give it much of a chance. Jeff did say on this deliberation and on Twitter that it wouldn't have had a chance on the top 3 of the Styyyyyyyyle category regardless. It won't be up for consideration next year because they go strictly by years.
I hadn't watched this yet, so I guess that makes sense.
Sadness. I would be curious to see if they still feel that way now that they've had even more time with the game.