While I had "heard" about there being controversy with JKR years ago I never really read up on the details or investigated the matter myself.
My re-introduction to this whole situation arrived when some GB staff would moan when a trailer for Hogwarts Legacy came up during events. That piqued my interest and I looked into what would create that response. I'm not well versed on all events that have lead to this moment, I can't quote what people have said or written, and I don't know the details of what financial arrangements have been funded or put in place.
I take it that some members from the trans community and their supporters take extreme offense at comments and actions made by JKR. Ok, that is their choice to make. In addition, there are a bunch of terrible people that are directly assaulting (verbally, physically, emotionally etc) people in this group on a daily basis. I wish platform holders were better at removing this kind of behaviour from their services. It's saddening that online or offline we can't eliminate belligerent mindsets.
Now with all that said. The discourse I've seen around this game is not entirely captured in the above paragraph.
In addition to the above, I have seen some pretty horrible abuse (in the league of death threats) sent to some people on Twitter, seemingly, because they said they were either going to purchase or stream the game online. The people targeted were not abusing others or harassing people.
I think this is where the pushback against the boycott comes from. The general public may see a prominent person receive vile abuse for purchasing something that to them seems innocuous. While they don't see the history of a community grappling with hate, they do see abuse. It just so happens they see abuse of people outside the trans community and this undercuts the entire message about safety, and inclusion.
TLDR: the entire LGBTQ+ community has dealt with so much shit over the years when they shouldn't have had to. This continues including in the space of Hogwarts Legacy. Unfortunately, some in the trans community raged out and sent some vile abuse to people who were not attacking the trans community. The bystanders watching this are confused when both parties have shitheads with no moral high ground.
Edits: typos, oh and I would put myself in the category of a trans community supporter having advocated for change in my area, but I think some in the trans community might disagree if I end up purchasing this game.
Log in to comment