I don't give a fuck so long as it's not intentional and a sweeping generalisation with negative overtones. I'm Welsh (the part of land bolted onto the left hand side of England) and although I don't even live there anymore, I thought it was "tidy" (fun/positive/useful/etc, a good catch all phrase from Wales) to have a Welsh accent in Ni No Kuni for the sidekick. I think it brought something novel to the game, Brad seemed to be into it. In fact I just got back a couple of hours ago from a comedy gig where a comedian was comparing the Welsh and Indian (South Asia) accents, and he was saying that as someone with an English accent it was easy to accidentally slip between the two. It led to a sketch about how accents change whilst under the influence of heavy drugs, and I just found myself laughing so hard.
On the other hand If anybody onstage or in a heated discussion made fun of the Welsh accent, intentionally to demean Welsh people or to try to gain points in an argument, then I would be offended. That's not the place for that, and not particularly clever.
I can't complain about actors in general pretending to have other accents either:
Hugh Laurie (English) - House
Christian Bale (Welsh) - Batman, American Psycho
Idris Elba (English) - The Wire
Sean Connery (Scottish) - The Hunt for Red October
Dick Van Dyke (US) - Mary Poppins
Ok the first three are passable (perhaps great - I'm not from US shores), but the second two just get a pass for being so abysmal that they're funny.
One further thing, if an accent is used to make fun it's very often that it's an individual that is being imitated e.g. Tina Fey as Sarah Palin. That's an entirely different question though, that the poll doesn't cover.
Log in to comment