This is such a weird game, for the most part critics don't like it, but people on gaming forums do.
Personally, I don't trust Giant Bomb to tell me if a game is worth playing. The last time I was tricked was Axiom Verge, man I hate that game. I have wondered why this is and I think it's because game critics look for the bad parts of games and expand on that whereas I look at the good points. Someone I watch is Totalbiscuit (which is ridiculous as I play on consoles exclusively) and he does say he looks for bad stuff to talk about.