@fnrslvr said:
I don't know dude, it just doesn't seem like the vendors make the case for moving up from this K6, M5, etc. price tier, to the Hero, Sabertooth, M7, etc. tier, all that clear at all -- and it annoys the hell out of me. Reviewers don't make the case clear either, and yet they seem to endorse this entire tier of boards without taking a moment to address the (to me) obvious question of what you're getting over the tier below or what you're missing out on from the tier above. I know you've been trying to drive home your take that there's no difference and that the correct decision is to get the cheapest model that has the features, but the very existence of this elaborate pricing hierarchy drives me mad. Are they just shilling snake oil to fools, or is there a legitimate customer for each of these boards? At this point I could probably find the extra $50-$100 if I felt like I was going to get a meaningfully better component, like I'm willing to spend more on the PSU, but even after studying this intensively I don't see the point.
It's all hot bullshit. Or, at the very least, I've never seen any hard data telling me otherwise. A good mid-tier board will last you more years than you'd care to keep it, and outside of a few nice but not critical extras (and the obvious caveat about the voltage regulation/overclocking potential, but that's such a small subset of the market that those people hardly need my help in choosing hardware), I've always shaken my head when people spend huge amounts on the motherboard, especially when they may have a substandard PSU. I mean, given unlimited money, I'd go nuts. I'd eat a Maximus VII Sabercat Ultra Tough Edition ROG Black right up. No reason not to do it. But without unlimited funds, I'm going to take the $50 or $100 or $200 I could blow on a board that no one can really tell me what I'm getting out of it, and get a better GPU, or a bigger SSD, or even faster RAM.
Let me go back to my example of the craziest Z170 board out there, in the closing of this review from Tweaktown:
I want to take a second and discuss the value of this $500 Z170 motherboard. It's no secret that differentiation is hard to provide and even harder to communicate with the Z170 chipset. Since so many features are provided through the PCH and CPU clocks are roughly the same among boards, many users are just fine with a sub $200 motherboard. The truth is that these higher priced boards might cost a premium, but there are features that add to their cost.
It then goes on to talk about overclocking related features, a built-in wireless card, and a Thunderbolt port. That's it. That's what the most extreme of the extreme can get you, so how little must the sub $300 offerings have to differentiate themselves? Hell, that crazy board can't even do 3/4 way SLI! (In fact, none of them can, unless they have an add-on PLX chip.)
So, it may be a case of the normal offerings being good enough, and the crazier offerings being a bit better, that causes the reviews to endorse what they do. There's nothing wrong with those more expensive boards, after all. Or, it could be more nefarious; the people usually interested in this stuff would be the ones visiting these sites, so the reviews reading like marketing pitches may be a bit intentional. I can't say, all I know is that in recent years, your choice of motherboard really has never mattered less when you enter the murky middle of the product line. As long as the board you receive is working the way it should, you'll hopefully never know that it's there, and it'll perform to a roughly equivalent degree both in terms of operation and longevity as something more expensive.
You're a well informed duder. You probably know more than I do given what I've read, or at the very least you're more informed about the (lack of) differences between your choices. Don't fret over it; trust that if you can't see a striking, glaring difference, that there isn't one. Your part selection looks excellent to me. With the addition of your storage drives and your GPU of choice, you'll have a killer system.
Log in to comment