Arkham City, I loved Asylum and people seem to really like City, but man I was just bored and uninterested the whole time.
I almost blew it with Arkham City, I think making it open was a mistake.
For a while I was compelled to wander looking for the whatnots scattered through the overworld. Once I said eff it and just mainlined the story (and major villain side-quests) the game flowed a lot better for me.
I honestly don't believe all you guys who have "nothing new to play" right now have played all the great games that came out last year. there must be one or two titles you missed out on or thought were not worth full price that are now dirt cheap.
lol, I know right. I still have the majority of 2011 in my backlog.