Yeah, so I got out with four people. Mike, Ash, Chris and Emily (what an odd mix). Jess died first, like 20 mins into the game. I wasn't fast enough with Mike it seems like. Matt was put on a meathook by a Wendigo. Don't really know what I did wrong there. The Butterfly effect said that he didn't have a weapon but he left his axe in the tower, and shot away a flare, so I would be interested to know what the rest of you did (I didn't get a QTE or anything to be able to save him). Josh died in the cave (by the "hands" of his sister no less!) right at the end. And Sam died when I couldn't keep the f-in controller still in the house right before the explosion. I had some REAL problems with that, it seemed to keep drifting all the time. That one stinged I have to admit.
Like previous posters, I also wonder how the psychologist plays in to the story (if at all). I told him early that I feared the dark and he kept berating me for keeping running into the dark.. Which hit home in some strange way.
All in all, I'm happy with the experience, and I liked how "my" story played out. But some of the things Brad speculated about in the QL seems off. Like there can't be different psychos, right?