Chakushin Ari (aka One Missed Call), 2003
Maybe watching it immediately after the generic and corny Teketeke (2009) made me too lenient on this movie, but I would call Chakushin Ari a pleasantly competent J-horror. Obviously it owes a lot to movies like Ringu, but the mere act of copying a great movie doesn't ever bother me. What matters is (a) studying and understanding what you copied rather than aping it, and (b) supplementing borrowed ideas with some of your own creativity.
Chakushin Ari does a nice solid job of (a) for the most part - it hits the beats you expect, and it hits them with feeling, if not with any great skill. For one thing, it's not patient in getting to the scary stuff, and in a movie that's maybe 30 minutes too long, this starts to put a real damper on the scary stuff. But the creepy parts themselves are quite good (especially the TV show scene), and the movie does manage some creativity in spots; when some crucial backstory started to emerge about 2/3rds in, I was intrigued by those themes and hoped to see them evolve.
Well, they kinda don't. From then on, the movie busies itself with a new spooky location, a couple "so-what?" plot twists, and eventually
full-on ambiguity, culminating in a perfectly inscrutable ending that can easily be called brilliant, or empty, or brilliantly empty, like any inscrutable ending. To me it was disappointing, and I don't think it's low-brow of me to be disappointed. I have nothing against ambiguity in fiction, and it can work extremely well in short-form horror, or when sprinkled into a longer story. But to string me along for over an hour with a pretty standard supernatural mystery, putting so much weight on the convolutions of the plot, and then stick me with an art-house ending that I'm (presumably) supposed to enjoy being utterly nonplussed by? No. That just sucks. (And yes I know Miike directed and that's his thing. I don't care. It did not fit this movie.)
Anyway. Like I said, pleasantly competent. The things it does best were done much better by Ringu and a few other movies, but if you're like me, J-horror in this vein is satisfying as long as it's, shall we say, "workmanlike." Chakushin Ari is workmanlike for long enough to get away with its eventual failures, and end up as a fun, if not particularly creepy, movie.
3/5
Log in to comment