This might take a while.
Halo: Combat Evolved - when it first opens up my young self was amazed by the freedom and scale compared to the fps games I'd played prior. Not to mention the enemy AI (it's still good), sticking an enemy for the first time, bouncing warthogs off each other... God I love halo.
Ocarina of Time - maybe the best video game of all time, the sense of wonder and excitement when I first played hasn't really been matched. That might be because I was a child or it might be because it's just that good.
Final Fantasy IX - the best final fantasy game (tactics is very good and I won't argue if you tell me it's better), it made me care about characters in a way no video game had yet, and so the pivotal moments in the story felt so impactful and dramatic to me. Add extremely impressive cgi cutscenes and the best graphics the PSX could muster and you've got a video game that blew me away.
The Last of Us - I didn't play this Until I got a PS4, and I was afraid the hype might have sunk it before I even played it, but man was I wrong. The way it builds its characters and narrative is really impressive, as is the quality of the world-building and detail. The story you uncover in the sewer area is better than most main video game plots. There are also some real moments of tension in the gameplay, and while it isn't my favourite playing game, it's still quite good in that department as well. I don't feel like replaying it because I know it won't be the same.
Gone Home - changed the way I thought about games and made me want to explore every nook and cranny so I understood everything I could.
Dark Souls - my first time through dark souls I had a friend explain some of the obtuse shit to me without holding my hand too much. It was a game I had avoided because I wasn't sure if it was for me, but I found that he game wasn't brutally hard like some people like to make out, but it tells you as little as possible and forces you to learn from death. Once you figure out your first souls game, the subsequent ones you play won't really be the same. Dark Souls is still the only one I've finished.
The thing about game experiences you wish you could have for the first time again is that they're often very time-dependent. I think these games are still "good", but the older ones are not necessarily going to be the mind-blowing experiences they were the first time if someone were today them for the first time today.
Log in to comment