I just spent like 6 hours straight playing it up until the first Cyberdemon fight. It's already one of the top 5 best shooters I've ever played. The gameplay is just fucking insane and always so much fun, there's a ton of variations on the weapons so you're never forced into one style, the maps are huge, and the story is both hilarious and awesome. I also happen to really enjoy the melee executioners in practice, I wasn't sold on them until I saw how they really integrate with the flow of the game. They do a really good job at breaking up all the shooting and adding some styyyyyyle into the mix. This really is the perfect Doom game, easy GOTY material and I'd frankly be shocked if shooter fans like Jeff don't like it.