Game of the Lists List
Inspired by @mento's reworking of his GOTY lists with games he's played since then, this list is going to be an amalgation of all the games listed within my GOTY lists, and then reordered from best to worst. As history has changed my opinions on some of these games, their rankings in comparison to my GOTY lists might change.
This one might take me a while, so consider it a work in progress. After taking a look at some of my earliest GOTY lists, I'm also going to open this up to "games played thoroughly" lists I've created through the years. For some reason, some of the top games from those years were absent from my GOTY lists, probably because I didn't put games that came out that year on the list.