TiggyTog

Tbh I'm also surprised 3 is doing so poorly, on a lot of top 10 lists I always see that game as number 1.

I'm surprised 2 is winning, on the other websites it's usually 1 that wins.

@thechris: Ye both of them were HEAVILY inspired by Berserk.

@christoffer: You didn't like climbing on a flying monster and stabbing it in the eye making it spiral into the ground? Or lighting a griffin on fire, preventing it from flying at all?

The boss fights are super dynamic and some of the best in gaming and the best part is you can do it a hundred times without getting marred down by stupid story BS.

I just think, art-style, where they were made, the implications of the story...

I think you can compare linear and open-ended games. To me those aren't apples to oranges.

@ryuku_ryosake: word

@darkmoney52: I wouldn't say Dogma is "without extreme lows".

The world, while beautiful, doesn't have nearly as much to discover as say, Skyrim. It's not a bad open-world by any means, but it isn't filled to the brim with detail as it should be, it's also very small in comparison to most video game worlds.

The story and especially the characters and sidequests have many issues, but the story does close off very well, excellent ending.

Monster placement can be annoying, it's very hard to find rarer enemies outside of Bitterblack Isle.

Fast Travel comes in early if you get the Eternal Ferrystone as soon as you get to Gran Soren, but unless you're hunting for Portcrystals the journey will still have some very long slogs from point A to point B.

Game has trouble nailing the JUST right difficulty, you're usually almost always severely underpowered or severely overpowered.

Jesus the votes tho lol.

Over on gamefaqs Dogma was beating Souls:

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/189706-nintendo-switch/78150578

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/691087-playstation-4/78406774

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/927750-playstation-3/68153449

@guardianbob87: I think them being Action-RPG's should be enough, it shouldn't matter what they FOCUS on, it should matter what kind of genre they are, that's just what I believe.

You're welcome to believe different though, thats just what I personally believe and I think I have that right, haha.

Besides, fun factor is one of the biggest things that come up in comparison, and that's always 100% subjective.

If you compare them walking side-by-side, their base attacks, special attacks, comparing grounded combat and such they can be compared openly enough.

I like to say, play a game side-by-side and if they look too odd next to one another, they can't be compared.

Like, example, Left 4 Dead and Dead Island, both zombie games but way too different to be compared.

This is something in the same exact genre, it shouldn't matter what they were going for and if they have a different FEEL, it should matter more what they look like side-by-side when compared directly visually. That's just how I personally feel.