And now, ladies and gentlemen... My favorite games of 2012!!!
On a side note, I've unfortunately not had time to play Far Cry 3. From the looks of it, it could easily earn a spot on my list but I can't add it without having played it yet. So lets say it gets an honorable mention.
Edit from the future (2015): After looking through my old lists, I'm tempted to move Mists of Pandaria up to near the top if not number 1. It's easily one of my favorite expansions. It feels a little wrong to do so, so I'll leave it where it is for now.
After commenting on my 2013 list, I came here to eye over some of the choices I made. I thought to myself, "wow! I can't believe I had MoP so low! I would probably move that higher if I were ordering this list today." Then I glanced at this section and noticed the same thought that I made a year ago. I couldn't help but laugh, as I had completely forgotten that I had done that.