I know it was free- but would anyone have really paid to do stuff you could mostly already do in some way shape or form? Most of it seems to be essentially just raids on bandit hideouts.

Haven't tried it yet but I feel that anything free is good!

I wouldn't have payed more than five bucks for it. But I am having some fun with it, since it's essentially some of the games single player missions in Co-Op form. It's nice to actually have some resemblance of objectives instead of go here and kill everyone. I believe Rockstar has said they're going to put out some more DLC over the summer, which would be pretty awesome.

yea its pretty disappointing. but then so was all of the multiplayer. free roam is pretty lame itself. I just traded this game in towards credit for transformers. i hope i like that game more.

" I know it was free- but would anyone have really paid to do stuff you could mostly already do in some way shape or form? Most of it seems to be essentially just raids on bandit hideouts. "

I think it's pretty good, even besides its price...and well lack thereof.

It was free. Why would I be disappointed?

Who in the right mind would be disappointed about a free dlc? 

free or not...
 
I saw the video and could tell it looked like stuff that was already in the game.  Looks like the exact same stuff you can do if you just form a posse in free roam and take on hideouts.  Now, I haven't d/led it but is there any difference at all?  I just beat singleplayer so I'll probably get it tho and check it out now when I have time.
 
Man, if they released more missions that take place after the game is over....I'd totally pay a pretty penny for that tho.  I really loved this game.

" I know it was free- but would anyone have really paid to do stuff you could mostly already do in some way shape or form? Most of it seems to be essentially just raids on bandit hideouts. "

" free or not...  I saw the video and could tell it looked like stuff that was already in the game.  Looks like the exact same stuff you can do if you just form a posse in free roam and take on hideouts.  Now, I haven't d/led it but is there any difference at all?  I just beat singleplayer so I'll probably get it tho and check it out now when I have time.  Man, if they released more missions that take place after the game is over....I'd totally pay a pretty penny for that tho.  I really loved this game. "

Given the limitations of the game world, they've come up with pretty clever ideas. I could see more potential if they listen to fan feedback for the next free DLC.

At least its free unlike most dlc

Free = good. 

It was FREEE, No what if this or that, IT WAS FREE!!!!!!!!

Seriously, I would NEVER pay for this, multiplayer isn't Red Dead's strong (...or fun) point, so it was a good move to make it free.

BTW I must shamefully promote my own review here for the DLC... ;P...yes, it is a MUST.

I was going to try it while playing with Ahmad_Metallic, but in the middle of playing, HE FELL ASLEEP! I'm not even kidding! He just stopped moving and then messaged me about 6-7 minutes later saying that he was sleepy!

I really liked the game but I would have passed on the DLC is it wasn't free. I wish it was just straight up single player missions rather than co-op. I jumped into it after a bit of a break from Read Dead and the group of assholes I got thrown in with reminded me why I stopped playing. I left and probably will trade the game in.

But....it was free!

I've had some good fun with it.

While I appreciate Rockstar for releasing a free DLC, I honestly did not find it very compelling. Of all the missions I think I enjoyed Walton's Gold the most. It makes me hope for more coop robbery missions where you, say, go from town to town robbing banks or hijack a train or something.

" yea its pretty disappointing. but then so was all of the multiplayer. free roam is pretty lame itself. I just traded this game in towards credit for transformers. i hope i like that game more. "

Well, it actually got more of my friends into the multiplayer, so I'm grateful for that. The narrative voiceover is actually kinda unintentionally funny, too. I dig it.