How many times have you gone through this game? For me, it had fantastic replay value, but unlike Mass Effect 2 (another 20+ hour game that came out the same year), it didn't have the start a new game and play through again replay ability. I just did everything that I could possibly do in the game's first play through (excluding all the unlock-able costumes), and including the DLC. I'm just wondering if anyone had a different feeling, and beat it more than once. I mean, it's good enough, it just doesn't seem like the type of game I would do that on though.
That's where the sequel leads me; I just don't feel like I have much reason to play it again if there isn't a sequel. I usually love playing previous installments of great games in a series when I know there's a sequel/prequel coming. Wow, you know what? I have all the GTA games, and I've never beaten one. I've only played for about 10 hours, maybe a little more, of any of them. So I know them well, but I don't know the full experience. I wish GTA 4 had some of the improvements Red Dead had. Anyways, that was random.