P3P is far and away my favourite version. The lack of cutscenes does suck, sure, but there were barely any of them in the game, and even fewer were the occasions where having low-poly puppets walking around actually mattered. The Answer is no big loss. What I really like about P3P is the female route, and that means a protagonist who isn't necessarily a heartless social vampire who manipulates everyone around him into liking him more, the ability to choose whether or not to have a romantic relationship with members of the opposite sex, the ability to form social links with your teammates e.g. the characters deeply involved in the main plot who are supposed to be like family to you, a Shinjiro who gets the chance to be an actual developed character instead of a gruff piece of cardboard with no emotional weight to his story arc beyond the effect it has on other characters, and no more forced participation in stupid pointless bullshit where your character humiliates himself for no reason. (No, Junpei, I don't want to fucking help you harass girls on the beach, I already have a girlfriend back home.)
Also, I didn't notice until I went back to FES to play The Answer, but fights in P3P move way quicker than in previous versions. All the character animations play faster. Makes those long dungeon crawls a lot more bearable. Also, the revamped fatigue system means you have a lot more freedom with your visits to Tartarus, putting more weight on SP management like in P4. Like the ally control, it's one of those things that some people probably prefer about the original, but the game is a lot more accessible as a result. And the fact that Academics no longer takes a billion points to progress is a nice bonus as well.
I can definitely see why people prefer FES, but it's just no contest for me.
Log in to comment