A bit overkill...

Avatar image for oneeyedninja7
#1 Posted by OneEyedNinja7 (920 posts) -

Or at least I think so. Discuss.

Avatar image for vinchenzo
#2 Posted by Vinchenzo (6463 posts) -

People will do anything to "be on top." You're not contributing when all you are doing is farming points. Sad in my opinion, but who cares. We know who the quality contributors are.

Avatar image for kush
#3 Posted by Kush (9089 posts) -

Stuff like this will never stop happening until the staff puts in new rules for submissions that are more strict, which I don't think will happen.

Avatar image for kindgalaxy
#4 Posted by KindGalaxy (462 posts) -

Needs more image submissions.

Avatar image for lordandrew
#5 Posted by LordAndrew (14601 posts) -
KindGalaxy said:
"Needs more image submissions."
I'm in the image moderation tool right now, and it looks like you're about to get your wish. :(
Avatar image for endogene
#6 Posted by Endogene (5183 posts) -

WTF.... I am ok with linking this concept to games that use shoes as a game play element...
But this is something different, this is just linking every single game you can think of...

Avatar image for silverbucket
#7 Posted by Silverbucket (263 posts) -

Actually, any game or anyone with shoes is a valid entry, and that's the problem. I could go on forever putting in games and characters with shoes. The problem is it's too general. Guns and Swords are general too but not all games have one and not all characters can be linked to them. I think they should ban any objects that are too general in terms. If they allow shoes, then what's next, hair? pants? shirts?.  For example, something specific should be, sneakers, sandals, golf shoes, you get my point.

BTW,  I'm not a point junkie, I really usually come here because I have nothing better to do. In fact, I couldn't care less about being on top, I mean, what do I get for being number one? A million dollar prize?

Avatar image for lordandrew
#8 Posted by LordAndrew (14601 posts) -

Guns and swords are actually relevant to games though. Shoes aren't.

Avatar image for cube
#9 Posted by Cube (4385 posts) -

This is retarded.

Avatar image for biggerbomb
#10 Edited by BiggerBomb (7011 posts) -

Why not? Someone should make a page for cufflinks.

Edit: Too late! I proposed to make the page. You snooze you lose!

Avatar image for silverbucket
#11 Edited by Silverbucket (263 posts) -
LordAndrew said:
"Guns and swords are actually relevant to games though. Shoes aren't."


The rules state any in-game object is valid, if shoes are in the game, then it's a valid entry whether it adds to the gameplay or not. A serious flaw in my opinion. Well, if the rules aren't changed, I'm going to add shoes to a few more characters that I like, I suggest everybody else to do the same.
Avatar image for gunner
#12 Posted by Gunner (4404 posts) -

If hamburgers can be an object, why can't shoes? I think this was the idea to begin with.

Avatar image for silverbucket
#13 Edited by Silverbucket (263 posts) -
Gunner said:
"If hamburgers can be an object, why can't shoes? I think this was the idea to begin with."
Hamburgers are not general terms, it's specific, shoes have large sub categories. Like for hair, it could be blonde, brunette, spiky hair, Mohawk, ect. instead of all on one page. At least, that's what I think the problem is.
Avatar image for pause
#14 Posted by pause422 (6334 posts) -

Its just people being points whores, and until its acknowledged, keep expecting more stupid shit on this level.

Avatar image for thegreatguero
#15 Posted by TheGreatGuero (8881 posts) -

If a game has shoes as a special item, like shoes that make you run faster, I think that's acceptable. Also, games with customizable shoes might be okay here as well. However, listing every single game to ever feature a character with shoes is just nuts.

Avatar image for kindgalaxy
#16 Posted by KindGalaxy (462 posts) -

ffs only two images, what the hell, i'ma start submitting 8bit art of mario shoes in a sec

Avatar image for oneeyedninja7
#17 Posted by OneEyedNinja7 (920 posts) -
This is something Jeff said in the Grass object forum, and I think it applies here as well. I think the community would rather have something as common as shoes linked to games that actually use shoes as a gameplay element or at least something customizable (i.e. being able to change the shoes you wear over the course of a game).


Jeff
said:
When it comes to pages for extremely common topics like this one, we want extraordinary uses of the object. For grass, that could mean grass plays a major part in the story line, or has a gameplay element to it, or is noteworthy from a technological standpoint. So something like Tony Hawk 2X, with its individual blades of grass, which was fairly unique in its day, should qualify.
Avatar image for babble
#18 Edited by Babble (1276 posts) -

Giant Bomb is a wiki, the fact is that linking allows searches to be made, things like grass or shoes can be relevant in a Wiki environment, sure not as much so as when looking at a gun or sword, but the connection still technically exists.

Trying to up your point count by uploading thousands of pictures of shoes is another thing.

Wiki's with point counts on them are going to be abused, it's up to the moderation team to not allow these concepts, otherwise there is no one to blame.

EDIT: Though I think Sneakers and the others should be combined as under just Shoes.

Avatar image for subway
#19 Posted by Subway (982 posts) -

I don't understand why people care if a page like this is up? Just don't look at it.

Avatar image for luckywanderdude
#20 Posted by LuckyWanderDude (863 posts) -

Anarchy! Anarchy! Anarchy!

Avatar image for willy105
#21 Posted by Willy105 (4915 posts) -

Farming points?

Sounds useful.

Avatar image for lordandrew
#22 Posted by LordAndrew (14601 posts) -
Subway said:
"I don't understand why people care if a page like this is up? Just don't look at it."
It's hard to avoid if it's attached to every game ever made.
Avatar image for jakob187
#23 Posted by jakob187 (22940 posts) -

o wow

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.