terrible
Star Wars: The Old Republic
Game » consists of 5 releases. Released Dec 20, 2011
Star Wars: The Old Republic is a massively-multiplayer role-playing game set 300 years after the events of BioWare's Knights of the Old Republic series, but still approximately 3,600 years before the events of the films.
BioWare adds segregated "Gay Planet"
I doubt this is part of some anti-gay Bioware agenda, I mean shit, these guys made Dragon Age II.
This is probably the cheapest and easiest way to implement same sex relationships, and considering that the dev team for TOR probably consists of two people with a jar of pennies at this point, it's hardly surprising.
More an oversight than an actively hurtful thing. They just wanted to add in same-sex relationships and did it at the same time adding in a new planet. They put the two together and failed to see the significance in leaving it that way. My guess is that it will be changed pretty quickly (even if some quests are just edited for the gay characters to appear on other planets for specific scenes etc...).
This is the least of that game's problems (but I guess from their point of view, when you run a f2p game - even bad publicity while get at least one new person to try the game and give them a little money).
I understand that Bioware is working on properly bringing same-gender relationships to the game in the future, and I do think people are picking on Bioware too much for this when they are probably the most committed developer in the industry when it comes to doing non-heterosexual relationships justice, and when they're one of the few developers who even give a damn about same-gender relationships, but none the less, the "Gay Planet" seems like a very poor and ham-fisted way to deal with the situation they are in. Instead of implementing a half-hearted stop-gap solution, they should have taken the time to make sure whatever they had produced in terms SGRs was well-made and did the concept justice before rolling it out.
@TheSouthernDandy said:
@Ravenlight said:
Knee-jerk reaction:
- WTF? They're segregating people by sexual orientation?
Reality:
- Bioware is adding same-sex content to the game and this one planet is just the start.
--
As usual, Slashdot fails to deliver on an accurate, unbiased summary.
Yup. Seems like an attempt to get people pissed off.
@Grimhild said:
@TheSouthernDandy said:
@Ravenlight said:
Knee-jerk reaction:
- WTF? They're segregating people by sexual orientation?
Reality:
- Bioware is adding same-sex content to the game and this one planet is just the start.
--
As usual, Slashdot fails to deliver on an accurate, unbiased summary.
Yup. Seems like an attempt to get people pissed off.
^^
It's a video game... also seeing as BioWare was totally cool with my getting my lesbian on in Mass Effect, why are they not okay with it in ToR?
@BlastProcessing said:
This is getting absurd. Wouldn't the right thing be having gay romance everywhere, instead of segregating it to a specific planet? This is basically the gaming equivalent of negro water fountains.
Also, are homosexuals getting tired of Bioware's shenanigans? I would imagine so.
Negro water fountains helped the economy because it led to twice the number of installations. Suddenly segregation's gone and plumbers are out of work. Go figure some libtard doesn't understand how the economy works.
The art of turning a good thing into a bad thing. Whoever wrote that is a genius. I'm surprised people even believed that they created a segregated gay planet considering Bioware are one of the few developers to even touch the subject of homosexuality and have done so rather well in my opinion. They created a universe where sexual orientation wasn't even talked about. I don't even remember hearing characters be surprised at another's sexual orientation during the Mass Effect games or even Dragon Age for that matter.
@Toxeia said:
It's a video game... also seeing as BioWare was totally cool with my getting my lesbian on in Mass Effect, why are they not okay with it in ToR?
@BlastProcessing said:
This is getting absurd. Wouldn't the right thing be having gay romance everywhere, instead of segregating it to a specific planet? This is basically the gaming equivalent of negro water fountains.
Also, are homosexuals getting tired of Bioware's shenanigans? I would imagine so.
Negro water fountains helped the economy because it led to twice the number of installations. Suddenly segregation's gone and plumbers are out of work. Go figure some libtard doesn't understand how the economy works.
Oh wow. Let's go down this road please.
@Toxeia said:
Negro water fountains helped the economy because it led to twice the number of installations. Suddenly segregation's gone and plumbers are out of work. Go figure some libtard doesn't understand how the economy works.
look at this guy
How strangely sensationalist. They explain that adding it in how they want is taking more time and resources than expected, especially with the free to play swap. That suggests a desire to continue to develop that content down the road, and that the current situation isn't the end of dev time on this specific feature.
@Toxeia said:
It's a video game... also seeing as BioWare was totally cool with my getting my lesbian on in Mass Effect, why are they not okay with it in ToR?
@BlastProcessing said:
This is getting absurd. Wouldn't the right thing be having gay romance everywhere, instead of segregating it to a specific planet? This is basically the gaming equivalent of negro water fountains.
Also, are homosexuals getting tired of Bioware's shenanigans? I would imagine so.
Negro water fountains helped the economy because it led to twice the number of installations. Suddenly segregation's gone and plumbers are out of work. Go figure some libtard doesn't understand how the economy works.
I don't think Bioware is the one who has a problem with gay and lesbian characters, I think Lucasarts is.
In the entirety of star wars cannon there is only one character that is gay. One. Two if you count juhani. And I think a list of every single EU SW character could fill an enclylopedia.
This isn't Bioware's fault. I mean, SWTOR is plenty mediocre, but this move isn't malicious at all.
Remember, this is the company that makes you BEAT BACK hamfisted advances from every single one of your party members (regardless of sex) in all their recent games.
Seriously, that shit is annoying. I hate Bioware romances, and how it defines their games so much. But that's a topic for another time.
Say what you will about familyphotoshoot, his thread titles are top notch.
Also, I can think of about fifty more important issues in TOR than... this. Crash and burn indeed, Bioware.
@SamDrugbringer said:
I don't think Bioware is the one who has a problem with gay and lesbian characters, I think Lucasarts is.
In the entirety of star wars cannon there is only one character that is gay. One. Two if you count juhani. And I think a list of every single EU SW character could fill an enclylopedia.
It has nothing to with either. Just how they add content. The story is being twisted.
Not disagreeing about the Star Wars canon though.
I just find some of the reaction funny considering Bioware is one of the very few developers to have homosexual romance in their games.
@Kidavenger said:
I don't understand why Bioware insists on injecting sexuality into it's games, everyone I ever knew that played MMOs seriously (or any game for that matter) did it as an escape/break from real life, who's secret escape is "Gay Planet"? Nobody. No straight people want to pretend to be gay other than to fuck with gay people and I can't imagine many gay people want to escape their gay real life to pretend to be gay.
Wait, what exactly are you saying?
Are you asking why would anyone want to bother with any romance options, regardless of the involved genders? Well, a lot of people just like doing that in games.
Or are you saying you believe that straight/gay/bi/pan/whatever gamers alike all just want to play as heterosexual characters? No. I don't believe that's true.
Man. That is a spectacular headline. Spectacular because it draws so much attention to something that is nowhere near as insane as the title would otherwise suggest.
Follow the Bioware development mindset:
- Releases game with NPC romances
- Fans complain that, unlike their prior games in their development catalogue, there are no same-sex relationship options (I think this is a warranted outcry, given Bioware's larger-than-normal LGBT community)
- While creating new content (read: Makeb), they decide to work same-sex relationship options into that new content as a response to the fans
This isn't a 'gay planet.' You aren't going to see lesbian Amazonian tribes, or gay space clubs, or anything like that. Rather, this is new narrative content that happens to accommodate something that the fans have been asking for. Naturally, re-recording all prior relationships in the game to include male and female characters is way more of a hassle than melding it with the new content.
@TheSouthernDandy said:
@Ravenlight said:
Knee-jerk reaction:
- WTF? They're segregating people by sexual orientation?
Reality:
- Bioware is adding same-sex content to the game and this one planet is just the start.
--
As usual, Slashdot fails to deliver on an accurate, unbiased summary.
Yup. Seems like an attempt to get people pissed off.
ive already seen one website take down there version of it for "misinformation"
people please, there saying now that there adding in same sex relations and a new planet so this article was all kind of a lie.
This, meaning that article, this topic and the responses, is why we can't have nice things.I like never agree with you but holy fucking shit are these people pants-on-head crazy.
Everything about this, from the sensationalist headline, the comments from either "side" of the issue, and the way Bioware has spectacularly bungled same/intersex relationships (while at the same time also being one of the only developers to try), make me shake my head.
I'm not going to look through the Bioware forums to confirm this is an actual comment, but nothing could be worse than it:
"Star Wars is a family-based story with nothing to do with SGR," wrote one user. "Please, please, please Bioware do not allow SGR in Star Wars The Old Republic. It will ruin the game and make a lot of people leave it."
What in all fucks is wrong with people?
And now I leave this conversation because the last time the subject was brought up on these forums I made one simple diplomatic comment and wound up being dragged into a shittstorm.
@DizzyMedal said:
@Kidavenger said:
I don't understand why Bioware insists on injecting sexuality into it's games, everyone I ever knew that played MMOs seriously (or any game for that matter) did it as an escape/break from real life, who's secret escape is "Gay Planet"? Nobody. No straight people want to pretend to be gay other than to fuck with gay people and I can't imagine many gay people want to escape their gay real life to pretend to be gay.
Wait, what exactly are you saying?
Are you asking why would anyone want to bother with any romance options, regardless of the involved genders? Well, a lot of people just like doing that in games.
Or are you saying you believe that straight/gay/bi/pan/whatever gamers alike all just want to play as heterosexual characters? No. I don't believe that's true.
That's not what I'm saying, it's more that someone that spends more time than the average person dealing with sexual issues in their day to day life, probably won't want to continue dealing with them in their escape.
Were people complaining about a lack of homosexuals in the rest of the game or something? Cause this seems like a dumbass solution to a dumbass problem.
Good on them for keeping their promises.
But they kinda invited this story - even if it is wrong - by the way they announced it, they should have waited with the gay content until it was done instead of releasing it one planet at a time (or in this case probably a planet, then the rest of the galaxy)...
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Comment and Save
Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment