If you suck at making Lemonade will you suck at making Limeade?

No because I suck at Street Fighter 2 but I'm a beast at Street Fighter 4.

I voted C. You're going to have to crack this conundrum on your own.

Yes.

" If you suck at making Lemonade will you suck at making Limeade? "

I can't play any other Street Fighter game worth jack, but I'm pretty good at SFIV. As much as people say it's like SFII, it's not, really.

To a point, yeah.  Soome of the basic stuff in SF2 also works in SF4.  You just need to practice.  Try renting the game and see if you like it enough to buy it.

im really good at Street fighter 2 but suck at SF4

they're very different. But you probably won't be great. But at least you won't suck

I voted "Yes" but I should have voted "I don't know".  Both games are conceptually the same but the battle mechanics are very different so I really don't know.

IMO SFIV feels little like SFII at all.

Yes, but you'll just have to practice.

You will at first, but I've found that SFIV has a much easier learning curve.  I played SFII for several years and wasn't that good, but I've gotten to a decent level at SFIV in a couple weeks.

Well the game is definently faster than street fighter 2 and having a background for street fighter games will definetly help you. Without that background, it would be difficult though. Give it a try and I think you will do alright, now it's a good time to get better at it. What they mean is that the moves are very similar to what your familar with before, it's not exactly the same.

Playing online will make you realize one of two things; one, that you are actually pretty good at SF4, or two, that you suck and you get extremely angry when you lose.
 
Guess what category I'm in >:(

SFIV is way less crazy and arcane than any game in the SFII series. I can personally vouch that it's faster to learn.

" im really good at Street fighter 2 but suck at SF4 "

sf4 was the first sf i took seriously, while i enjoyed all previous ones, i was by no means "good". if anything, i achieved king of the scrubs ranking amidst my friends, but my skills didn't build until sf4 hit. now i've found that my sf4 skills translate back to sf2, so i'm much better at the older games now than i ever was before. 
 
if you want to be good at sf4, you will be, just practice and have fun. in the end, you'll gain skills that crossover to other sf games and other fighting games as well.