Gaming Memories: Super Mario RPG

Avatar image for majormitch
Posted by MajorMitch (1158 posts) -

Welcome to “Gaming Memories,” a blog series where I reminisce about my favorite video games. I will slowly but surely get to every game on the list (and possibly beyond), and speak to why each holds a special place in my heart. That not only means I’ll talk about why I think each is a great game that speaks to my tastes, but also where and how it affected me in a larger context. I hope you enjoy, and thanks for reading.

SPOILER WARNING: This blog contains spoilers for Super Mario RPG.

There’s a fancy hotel in Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars called Marrymore Hotel. For the most part it works like any other inn in the game: you can pay a small fee to rest and heal up your party members. But Marrymore also has a fancy deluxe suite, which functionally serves little purpose. It’s also way more expensive, and you can choose to stay there for more nights than you can afford. Most video games wouldn’t let you do something you can’t afford, but Super Mario RPG isn’t most video games. If you stay for too many nights, your punishment is to work as a bellhop, performing tedious tasks to pay back your debt.

Mario RPG's combat had a great idea that's not been used enough.
Mario RPG's combat had a great idea that's not been used enough.

Super Mario RPG is a game full of character. That’s not limited to the actual characters in the game, but also the game itself. It has fun with the little details like Marrymore Hotel, which pays attention to your negligence and makes you pay in a playful way. NPCs in the world idolize Mario, imitating his jumps or playing with toy figurines. It rains when Mallow cries, Bowser kisses Mario at one point, you fight what are basically the Power Rangers, and it has this music. It’s a supremely silly game, but also a competent one; it never sacrifices its solid mechanics for a gag, which is the downfall of so many funny games. Super Mario RPG’s core loop is typical by JRPG standards of the time -- this was a collaboration with the Squaresoft of the 90s after all -- and crawling through dungeons, leveling up, and finding more powerful items and abilities works just as well here as in its contemporaries. Most importantly, Super Mario RPG leans into one fresh idea that I still don’t think is used enough. Timing additional button presses on your attacks and blocks greatly increases their effectiveness, which makes its turn-based battles feel surprisingly active. You have to constantly stay on your toes, and execute with perfect timing if you want to survive some of the game’s tougher battles. It’s exciting.

But Super Mario RPG is also a game full of characters. You of course have Mario, who is as expressive here as he is in any game. He is joined in the fight by both Peach and Bowser, which was a real treat at the time to see them fighting alongside our hero. But it’s perhaps original characters Mallow and Geno who steal the show among the main cast; Square’s writing chops are really let loose with them, and also with the game’s large and diverse cast of supporting characters. There’s Toadofsky, who you aid with his “composer’s block” by jumping on tadpoles to create music. There’s Johnny, the honor-bound shark pirate who turns to your side after seeing the cowardice of a foe. There’s Valentina and Dodo, who take control of Birdo and temporarily rule the land in the clouds. There’s Exor, the giant talking sword that jams itself into Bowser’s Keep at the start of the game, driving Bowser from his home and into an alliance with Mario. And of course, there is Booster. Who, um, well... is Booster. Your search for the titular seven stars takes you to every corner of the Mushroom Kingdom, interacting with all its wacky inhabitants along the way. Your adventures are not limited to funny encounters either: there are just enough serious, tense, and heartfelt moments sprinkled along the way to make this a more emotionally resonant game than it initially appears.

Don't we all.
Don't we all.

All of those features come together to make Super Mario RPG a polished, endearing game that is a blast to play. It also has a great look to it, and a wonderfully energetic soundtrack that remains one of my favorites. But the 90s were full of solid JRPGs; it took something extra to wiggle its way this far into my heart, which Super Mario RPG most certainly did. Looking back, it served as a fitting coda to numerous facets of my gaming youth. The SNES was the first gaming console my brother and I had for ourselves, and Super Mario RPG was one of the last great SNES games ever released, mere months before the launch of the Nintendo 64. Nintendo’s next console marked the end of not only the SNES era, but the 2D era as well, and Super Mario RPG captured so much of what was great about both. The SNES is almost certainly the console that’s had the largest impact on my gaming tastes, and it was dominated by Mario-inspired platformers and Square-developed JRPGs. Super Mario RPG, then, was a celebration of everything both Mario and Square. To this day it remains one of the few dream crossovers that, quite frankly, doesn’t suck, and it’s hard to imagine a better send-off for possibly the most defining period of my gaming history.

I picked up a SNES Classic Edition in early 2018, and spent a couple hours revisiting Super Mario RPG. Before then it had probably been at least 15 years since I last touched it, but it all came back in an instant: I was quoting lines of dialogue as if I had just seen them the day before. Super Mario RPG is part of my gaming DNA. Its music, its characters, its world, its combat; it’s all a part of me in a way that few games are. And it wouldn’t even work if it wasn’t an extremely well-made game either. Super Mario RPG is the perfect blend of charm and execution, a magical gaming cocktail that feels like home to me, even as it made its own home in my heart.

Avatar image for charlesfishman
#1 Posted by CharlesFishman (3 posts) -

Great write up, and weird timing. Im just about to finish my first playthrough of this gem, never had a super as I was a Sega kid. You did a great job articulating everything that has pulled me into this amazing work. Look forward to reading your future posts

Avatar image for majormitch
#2 Posted by MajorMitch (1158 posts) -

@charlesfishman: Thanks much!! That is weird timing, but it's nice to hear that this game holds up and still works for someone playing it for the first time now. I always liked to think that, but I'm also blinded by nostalgia on this one, so am pretty unqualified to say :)

Avatar image for turboman
#3 Posted by turboman (9852 posts) -

Good write up! SMRPG is one of my favorite games of all time and maybe my favorite game from the SNES catalog (sounds crazy, but I think that’s the case for me personally)

Just played through it recently and it super holds up! I remembered working at the hotel because I couldn’t pay the bill was the coolest thing when I was a kid.

Avatar image for zombiepenguin9
#5 Posted by zombiepenguin9 (747 posts) -

Enjoyed the read! I didn't have any Nintendo consoles growing up, so I never got a chance to play this when it was new. I recently picked up a SNES, and will probably pick this up if I ever run across it.

Avatar image for doctordonkey
#6 Posted by doctordonkey (1812 posts) -

Definitely one of those games that are once in a lifetime. It's my favourite SNES game and I found the lively writing and visual humor absolutely unmatched at the time. Timing focused turn-based combat remains underutilized even today, only being used well in the other Mario RPG series'. I could have seen something like Octopath Traveller use it to great effect.

Avatar image for majormitch
#7 Posted by MajorMitch (1158 posts) -

@turboman: Thanks!! That hotel moment really was kind of magical at the time :) And I don't think it's crazy to hold this as your favorite SNES game. There are a couple I probably like slightly more than Mario RPG, but it's right up there for sure, the margins are slim.

@zombiepenguin9: Thank you! If you do get to play it, I'd be curious how it holds up for you!

@doctordonkey: It is kind of wild how turn-based RPGs have rarely used any timing based component, or otherwise tried to be more active. It's one of my favorite things about all the Mario RPG games (including Paper Mario and Mario & Luigi), and I think it goes a long way towards combating the stereotypical complaint that JRPGs are slow and boring. Agree it would have been cool to see Octopath Traveler try it!

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.