So O'Malley the maker of Scott Pilgrim tweeted this -

"Telltale wanted to do Scott Pilgrim but I said no. I couldn’t see it as an adventure game. All respect to them, though"

This hurts, seeing as how much I love both Scott Pilgrim and Telltale seeing them both together would be amazing.

A video game that's full of video game references would be almost as garbage as the film.

Um...good. Telltale are already making 400 games. Perhaps they should start thinking of some IPs of their own.

I love Telltale but can't say I'm very fond of Scott Pilgrim.  I'd prefer they kept working on classic franchises or simply made something original.

Telltale could have probably dominated that shit, but I can't say I'm too torn up about it. The licenses they already have a hold of are far superior to Scott Pilgrim.

A telltale game could have been interesting but I can't really see what they would do with the license. 

" @NekuSakuraba:  Maybe it's just me, but playing through the game once with a friend was "OK". Nothing more.  I can't believe the over-hype that game got, and I can't believe you had to watch a 20min credits roll everytime you beat it. Maybe I'm just bitter because it was a pain in the ass to S-Rank. :P "

I'd have been more curious than anything else to see how a traditional Telltale game would play around Scott Pilgrim.. 
Also, movie rocked.

I love scott pilgrim to death and this would have been awesome. I wasn't a fan of the beat em up game so much, but an adventure game would've been great.  
They left a lot of awesome parts of the books out of the movie, an episodic game series would have been the perfect outlet to get all those parts in. 

" @NekuSakuraba: Love the comics. Movie was like yeah whatever. Game wasn't worth it. "

Good. I kinda heavily disliked Scott Pilgrim (the movie and the game, haven't read the comics).

" @Snapstacle said:

" @NekuSakuraba: Love the comics. Movie was like yeah whatever. Game wasn't worth it. "

What wasn't worth it?  River City Ransom? "

" @NekuSakuraba:  Maybe it's just me, but playing through the game once with a friend was "OK". Nothing more.  I can't believe the over-hype that game got, and I can't believe you had to watch a 20min credits roll everytime you beat it. Maybe I'm just bitter because it was a pain in the ass to S-Rank. :P "

" Good. I kinda heavily disliked Scott Pilgrim (the movie and the game, haven't read the comics). "

No you don't, you love them.  I am amazed by how much you people seem to hate or dislike the movie, it was pretty awesome in my opinion. >__< "

@NekuSakuraba said:

No you don't, you love them.  I am amazed by how much you people seem to hate or dislike the movie, it was pretty awesome in my opinion. >__< "

Just out of interest, how old are you? Scott Pilgrim seems like something squarely targeted towards teenagers.My guess is that many of the people that didn't enjoy the movie (game...comics...) are probably a little too old to be interested. 
 
It's definitely how I feel about the franchise. Maybe I would've been interested years ago, but I'm certainty not now.

The more I read about Telltale's future plans, the more of a joke they seem to be. They should really start on focusing more on making their products to a standard of quality rather than churning out as many games as possible. I couldn't envision Scott Pilgrim as an adventure game either and so I'm glad that they've declined Telltale the right to make one.

" @BeachThunder

@NekuSakuraba said:

No you don't, you love them.  I am amazed by how much you people seem to hate or dislike the movie, it was pretty awesome in my opinion. >__< "

Just out of interest, how old are you? Scott Pilgrim seems like something squarely targeted towards teenagers.My guess is that many of the people that didn't enjoy the movie (game...comics...) are probably a little too old to be interested. 
 
It's definitely how I feel about the franchise. Maybe I would've been interested years ago, but I'm certainty not now.

You do know most people who liked it were 20 or older? Look at Spill.com and Screened.com they liked it and they are all older than 20. Plus if it was aimed at teenagers as you said why would they add references to older games over newer ones? Not saying you can't like it, but I can't see how it was aimed at teens. "

" @BeachThunder

@NekuSakuraba said:

No you don't, you love them.  I am amazed by how much you people seem to hate or dislike the movie, it was pretty awesome in my opinion. >__< "

Just out of interest, how old are you? Scott Pilgrim seems like something squarely targeted towards teenagers.My guess is that many of the people that didn't enjoy the movie (game...comics...) are probably a little too old to be interested. 
 
It's definitely how I feel about the franchise. Maybe I would've been interested years ago, but I'm certainty not now.

You do know most people who liked it were 20 or older? Look at Spill.com and Screened.com they liked it and they are all older than 20. Plus if it was aimed at teenagers as you said why would they add references to older games over newer ones? Not saying you can't like it, but I can't see how it was aimed at teens. "