Recommend a game? Rise of the Tomb Raider or AC: Syndicate?

Avatar image for wonderva
Posted by wonderva (299 posts) 1 year, 2 months ago

Poll: Recommend a game? Rise of the Tomb Raider or AC: Syndicate? (58 votes)

Rise of the Tomb Raider 86%
AC: Syndicate 14%

Saw that the Xbox Summer Sale is starting, and I already purchased a few games. I have been waiting for digital copies of these games to be on sale, and now they are at the same price of $30. I'm a fan of AC2 and AC: Brotherhood, but I haven't played any AC game since then.

I don't have much experience with the Tomb Raider series, but for what it is worth, I just thought the Uncharted games were average to good, not great.

Avatar image for doomguy2
#1 Posted by doomguy2 (42 posts) -

Rise of the Tomb Raider, i'm not the AC series' biggest fan but Syndicate was just shite. They managed to make the combat worse somehow and the story was uninteresting. You can tell that the tomb raider games were heavily influenced by Uncharted, but the second one opens it up a lot gameplay wise and goes for more RPG focused mechanics.

Avatar image for justin258
#2 Edited by Justin258 (14755 posts) -

I really liked Assassin's Creed Syndicate, but that was the first Assassin's Creed game I've really played. I played some of 2 but not much.

I also think Uncharted is average to good and hardly deserving of the praise it gets, but I really enjoyed the first Tomb Raider. Rise of the Tomb Raider isn't a game that I enjoyed much. I haven't really gone back to play Tomb Raider 2013, but I have to wonder if I just happened to play it at the right time, when I was in the right mood. It is worth noting that Rise of the Tomb Raider does a lot more than Uncharted's linear, cinematic, on-rails levels. It's not an open world game, but you can spend hours in that game doing stuff other than shooting people, and you can fast travel back to pretty much any of the major hub areas to do sidequests, open stuff you couldn't open before, etc. I don't think either game is particularly bad and my opinion on Rise of the Tomb Raider seems to be the exception rather than the norm.

I say get Assassin's Creed Syndicate.

Avatar image for cikame
#3 Posted by cikame (2019 posts) -

I pick Syndicate for entirely personal reasons, i played it and liked it a whole bunch on PC but i like AC games so go figure, i played through the first of the reboot Tomb Raiders and while i recognise it as a good game, the animation quality was off-putting throughout and i absolutely hate Camilla Luddington's voice... when the new game was announced with the promise of more of the same i said no thanks.
Lots of people put it in their game of the year awards though so it's probably fantastic if you arn't me :P.

Avatar image for kedi2
#4 Posted by Kedi2 (329 posts) -

FYI the version of Assassin's Creed that comes with all of the DLC is also on sale for just an additional $6 ($36 total), so you may want to opt for that version if you end up choosing Assassin's Creed.

Avatar image for brandondryrock
#5 Posted by brandondryrock (872 posts) -

Personally I'd say Rise of the Tomb Raider is a better game, but based on how you enjoyed AC 2 and Brotherhood, I'd say Assassin's Creed. I really enjoyed AC Syndicate. I'm a big fan of the series. I've played them all except for Unity. AC Syndicate is probably my third favorite in the series, after Brotherhood and Black Flag.

Avatar image for cav829
#6 Edited by Cav829 (808 posts) -

Syndicate is in many ways like an updated take on Brotherhood. It's the best Assassin's Creed game in a while.

Rise of the Tomb Raider is the better game, but it has a bit of Uncharted feel if you weren't into that. The "parkour" aspect of Uncharted is toned down a bit and a little more involved, but I wouldn't go in expecting it to drastically change your opinion on that type of gameplay. The gunplay is not great, though the other combat mechanics are solid. I liked it quite a bit and think it's the better game, but I don't think you'd go wrong picking Syndicate if you're more into Assassin's Creed.

The poll is likely to go in Tomb Raider's favor, so don't entirely go off of that. It's the better game though IMO, but they're both 4 star quality games. I wrote reviews on both of them here and here.

Avatar image for cameron
#7 Posted by Cameron (973 posts) -

I thought Tomb Raider was a much better game. AC Syndicate is also quite good, but it still has too much open-world-jank for my tastes.

Avatar image for zombiepenguin9
#8 Posted by zombiepenguin9 (590 posts) -

I enjoyed Rise of the Tomb Raider a lot, but haven't had much interest in the Assassin's Creed series since AC3, so take my opinion with a grain of salt. RotTR is a gorgeous game, and I think it handles exploration, challenges/collectibles, and even stealth combat better than recent AC games. In terms of narrative, it doesn't accomplish anything more than the 2013 reboot, but the world and mechanics are done well enough where that's not really an issue for me.

Avatar image for goonage
#9 Posted by goonage (183 posts) -

Easily Rise of the Tomb Raider. Syndicate was an improvement for the AC series, but not by much.

Avatar image for edgaras1103
#10 Posted by edgaras1103 (796 posts) -

AC Syndicate is the best AC game since brotherhood. Main missions are lite hitman-ish style assassinations . The visuals are really good, the characters are decent and the overall story is not trash. It just has the atmosphere man , the Victorian London at night is I sight to behold. This game is a return to form for AC games.

Now RIse. I really liked 2013 reboot of tomb raider. It had nice visuals, and horror-ish vibe with nice gunplay and overall feel of desolate island. The sequel has couple nice things. The cutscenes are very nice and Lara's model is just absolutely amazing, from gameplay animations to cutscenes motion capture and the hair tech is best tech I have seen. Nearly everything else is worse. The story is even worse, the writing is horrible. The gunplay is weak, guns sounds like shit, the hub areas has too much padding there's no sense of place and atmosphere. Lara is even blander. The visuals are a mixed bag, so much pixel crawling and aliasing and the colors are so god damn brown and dull.

Get Syndicate.

Avatar image for christoffer
#11 Posted by Christoffer (2337 posts) -

I liked AC: Syndicate a whole bunch, but Rise of The Tomb Raider is a hell of a game, imo.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.