I think I liked the idea and approach of Serpent in the Staglands better than what I played in the demo. I also have trouble playing immortals for some reason.
Had a blast with Grimrock 2 but stalled out for some reason. Got pretty far and love it, though.
Morrowind, despite my love of most things Elder Scrolls, was the only ES game I actually beat, and overall was the one I think I enjoyed the most.
Dragonfall had some good writing. Not played the Hong Kong expansion. I guess you always start over every time you play, though. Not sure how I feel about the combat. Sometimes it's good, sometimes it feels a bit too... incremental?
Stalled out on Arcanum... I think because I reached a new place and it felt sort of empty. The game's scope expanded way beyond where I'd thought it was going to focus, but then I was having trouble keeping all the places straight because they seemed very vague somehow. Still don't know quite how I feel about this game, but that character system, yeah.
I have some of the others, but haven't even touched them yet.
ahoodedfigure's comments