A Devil’s Advocate Reviewing the Last of Us HBO Pilot
By infantpipoc 0 Comments
Yours truly is in the “minority” when it comes to the Last of Us. By which I mean I loathed it so deeply that I developed a general distrust regarding strangers on the internet telling me what’s “a great game”. It had been 8 years since I touched the game on PS3. So this new show on HBO presented itself as an opportunity for yours truly to play the devil’s advocate against this “masterpiece” more thoroughly without touching the actual game. I have not plan to do the episode review weekly, yet. But since I just watched this 81 minutes long episode titled “When you are in the dark”, I am dropping my two cent here. Spoiler of course is inevitable.
January, 2023 is a fun time to be alive as two piece of perhaps not all deservingly critically acclaimed video game post-apocalypse fiction came to the tv screen again. Only this time the interactivity got left behind. NieR Automata Ver 1.1a debuted on January, the seventh, and it sure is faithful to a fault. I mean why are camera pans indicates gameplay time still in this show’s pilot?
Then the Last of Us was unleashed on HBO on January, the fifteenth, a whole decade after to the week after Fringe (Well, LOU cast member Anna Torv is in it) aired it finale. Yours truly being a devil’s advocate when it comes to the game this show is based on had considered skipping it. But alas, I just want to know. At least see the pilot and write about can make the 82 minutes I spent on watching not a totally waste.
I got to say despite the first 3 minutes being a completely waste, that’s the only bit I like about this show.
Fungiphobia: Starting with a show stopper
It begins with 1968, and we are watching an abc talk show filmed in front of a live studio audience. No corner is cut there. We get a host and two guests, full behind the scene crew and an audience composed of extras in period costumes. One of the guests, played the underrated John Hannah. puts a mad scientist appearance to warn people about Fungi infection being the doom of humanity. It’s certainly the more effective horror story as the show just crosses off everything on a zombie fiction to-do list.
It is a fun scene, perhaps the only fun scene in the pilot. But it does not seem to fit into a zombie fiction all about “Men are the true walking dead”. Put this one in front of things like X-Files, Fringe episodes on tv or comic book B.P.R.D. issue where fungi infection is just another mystery to be solved, this scene would have been a nice set-up. But it’s the Last of Us where all its creators care is the aftermath.
Business as usual
After open credits we jumped to 2003. Guess this show wants to connect with its audience by having it being an alternative reality of current time instead of a near future setting. We have the last day of Joel Miller’s normal life. His daughter cooked him breakfast, his brother Tommy came over to tell him about work. He went to work and the focus became solely on his daughter. Help the neighbour, go to school and get his watch fixed. And people who run the watch shop sure seem spooked about all the police and even military presentation on the street.
Then the first scene of the video game starts at the 15th minute time mark. All above is meant to make one care about Sarah or Sally, you know the doomed daughter of the game’s player character Joel. I don’t think it’s a prestige thing. 9 out of 10 horror movies from the last decade, even the ones yours truly thoroughly enjoy, has this type of “first act problem”. Meaning, just skip to the genre bit and fucking stop manipulating me into caring about obviously doomed characters.
Once them mushroom(though no moving one is visible so in this pilot) zombie appears, yours truly began to think if they were watching a parody. What’s her name Miller went into a neighbour’s house and there were a flesh eating zombie in it. My mind is split between “This is just how people with no idea first see zombie in fiction like this” and “Why did they do a shot-for-shot recreation of first zombie appearing in original Resident Evil?” Greatest video game story? I think not.
Desolation Row
“Present day”, Boston. A kid walks towards the highly fortified Boston. The soldiers on watch takes them in, restrains them and starts to inspect them according to procedure printed and pulled up the wall. The kid tested positive of fungi infection, killed off the screen and dumped for the broke man of a lead Joel to burn as part of a labour he does for the city.
Ah, yes, no moving to zombie to kill, the post-apocalypse bit of this episode is all about “Men are the real walking dead”. FREDA is a fucked-up military government over Boston, Firefly is a revolutionary movement to overthrow it rather recklessly. If Bioshock Infinite can be criticized for its “both sides are bad” statement, then it’s truly baffling why the Last of Us get away with it.
At least the cast is good here.
Pedro Pascal as Joel is fine. Stoic is obviously a facade he put up. As far as player character in a game goes, he only commits three acts of violence here. First being done the first on-screen zombie’s head in 2003. Second being his first contact with Ellie actually. Well, she does charge at him with a knife, so it’s self-defense instead of abuse. The last being at the end of the episode, after having flashback about his daughter being gunned down by a solider, he just bashes another solider’s head in after said soldier points a rifle at him.
Bella Ramsey as Ellie is pitch perfect in every way. Voice and tune is as if Ashley Johnson herself did the dubbing. The timing of curse is better here, but that just might be a tv over game thing.
Anna Torfv as Tess is quite a surprise here, but I am heavily bias on this case since I like her performance on Fringe. Her laconic reference of famous men just made me put “coward” on my list of why Neil Drukmann is overrated. She calls Marlene “Che Guevara of Boston” some screen time after telling Joel not to go “Clint Eastwood”. Which Eastwood would be my question since there is the cowboy then there is Nazi killing machine in Where the Eagles Dare.
Verdict? I hope so
I dare say as a piece pf prestige tv, the Last of Us on HBO is a jack of all trades and master of none. As some review points out the pilot is more interested in aftermath of violence than the act of violence. So, if you want video game level body count, may I recommend you to look up Strike Back, probably watchable on HBO Max as well. All that dramatic bit just made yours truly think “Maybe I should go back to Station Eleven”. The whole endeavor just feels pointless in more than one way.
I don’t know if fan of the game would love this game, for A gamers are truly a unhinged bunch and B not to mention the weirdos not happy with casting. But as a devil advocate against the game, the pilot is not changing my mind one bit.
Log in to comment