Cookies or Brownies

I say cookies. brownies require too much milk.

I have to agree with ya, Cookies are the way to go

Cookies, but I do like brownies now and then.

Put your hands together!

Cookies only because they come in more varieties than brownies but damn brownies are good sometimes

Both are great, especially alone but when you add whip cream, vanilla ice cream, almonds, chocolate syrup and or hot fudge.

Depends on the kind of cookie... peanut butter cookies>brownies but brownies>oatmeal cookies lol

brownies are the best

I enjoy brownies more

Wow, it seems it takes only a single post to boot anything back to the front page

Fascinating

Cookies.

Cookies

dammit i think cookies

I prefer cookies over brownies. No special reason though, just do.

cookies FTW

A crappy cookie is better than a crappy brownie, but a great brownie trumps a great cookie any day.  I have to give it to cookies though, because truly great brownies are just way too rare.

Cookies.

Too hard to choose! >_>

Cookies, however.

Biscuits for me I think.

I moved this to Off-Topic.

That would depend on what mood Im in.
Right now I would like some brownies though

Cookies. Brownies are usually too chocolaty.

Cookies.

I'm a cookie fan myself. Especially the chocolate chip variety.

Cookies. Brownies have too much chocolate. I can only handle so much chocolate... :(

cookies

COOKIES!

brownies

cookies, brownies mess up my braces.

cookies, fa 'sho.

Brownies.

Do the brownies have frosting? If so, cookies. If not, brownies.

Cookies have more variation in quality. A good cookie is better than a brownie, but a brownie is better than a average to bad cookie. Also, frosting on brownies sucks like @mlarrabee said.

Way to necro an awesome thread.

It always depends. always.

I've had shitty cookies, And shitty brownies, but also the opposite.

but..... I guess.... cookies? in general.

A warm chocolate chip cookie straight out of the oven!

Cookie master race

Pot joke

@soopy: Next time make a poll. Statistics on this kind of thing are relevant.

ARE YOU FUCKING HIGH?

Milk is why brownies are fan-fucking-tastic you monster!

Cookies aren't even that good. Biscuits are where it's freakin' at. But good brownies and a giant glass of cold, whole milk over any of that any day. Especially when they are made with the edge pan thingy that makes all brownies edge brownies.

Crackers

Cookies are an entire category of food, while brownies are a very specific thing. Even if only for variety, cookies are the best.

@skytylz: Wasn't me, but "cookies or brownies" is an important life decision.

EDIT: I don't even know how this kind of thing happens. Are people browsing through hundreds of pages of past threads? Or was someone looking at the "Brownie" or "Cookie" wiki page and decided to go to the forums?

Hopefully he's learnt how to make a poll in the last four years.

white chocolate brownie with ice cream on top vs. white chocolate macadamia cookie

it's a toss up.

Most definitely cookies. All flavors included

Cookies. The flavour profile is all weird in brownies. They're like chocolate cake but denser and usually sweeter. Not my style.

Why are you bringing biscuits into this?

It depends on what mood I'm in, but mostly brownies, unless it's the holidays...then it's cookies all the way!

@skytylz: Wrong kind of biscuits. But I think I'd prefer either over most "cookies." Any kind of biscuits are fucking delicious in my book. Especially with a good strong cup of earl grey, hot.

Speaking of UK sweets, I really miss the ones that had like... pink marshmallowy stuff with coconut shavings on top. God those were fucking good. American sweets suck :(

@mordeaniischaos: I knew you meant UK biscuits, I just wanted to get the biscuits vs cookies name debate going.